kT/C: the noise you cannot design away

Measure the noise a resistor leaves on a capacitor, see why the resistor drops out of the answer, and size a sampling capacitor for a number of bits.

Lesson
E7.2
Time
25 min
Runs on
ngspice
Check
5 questions

A sample-and-hold had too much noise on its 1 pF hold capacitor, so its designer cut the switch's on-resistance from 10 kΩ to 1 kΩ to lower its thermal noise. The noise on the capacitor stayed at 64.37 µV rms, and a 100 kΩ switch would not have moved it either.

AC analysisNoise on 1 pF behind three resistorsThe running total: all the noise on the capacitor from 1 Hz up to each frequency, as an rms voltage.
  • R = 100 kΩ
  • R = 10 kΩ
  • R = 1 kΩ
010 µV20 µV30 µV40 µV50 µV60 µV70 µVTotal noise up to f1 Hz100 Hz10 kHz1 MHz100 MHz10 GHz1 THzFrequency√(kT/C) = 64.37 µV020 µV40 µV60 µV80 µVTotal noise up to f1 Hz10 kHz100 MHz1 THzFrequency√(kT/C) = 64.37 µV
  1. Frequency 100 kHzR = 100 kΩ = 12.87 µV · R = 10 kΩ = 4.071 µV · R = 1 kΩ = 1.287 µV

    At 100 kHz the 100 kΩ circuit has gathered the most noise: its resistor is the noisiest per hertz.

  2. Frequency 10 MHzR = 100 kΩ = 61.06 µV · R = 10 kΩ = 38.47 µV · R = 1 kΩ = 12.87 µV

    By 10 MHz the 100 kΩ curve has stopped rising. The 10 kΩ curve is still climbing and the 1 kΩ curve has barely started.

  3. Frequency 10 GHzR = 100 kΩ = 64.37 µV · R = 10 kΩ = 64.34 µV · R = 1 kΩ = 64.05 µV

    All three end at the same total, 64.37 µV: 1 kΩ, 10 kΩ and 100 kΩ alike.

Read the plot as a table
FrequencyR = 100 kΩR = 10 kΩR = 1 kΩ
1 Hz0 V0 V0 V
10 Hz122.1 nV38.62 nV12.21 nV
100 Hz405.1 nV128.1 nV40.51 nV
1 kHz1.287 µV406.9 nV128.7 nV
10 kHz4.071 µV1.287 µV407.1 nV
100 kHz12.87 µV4.071 µV1.287 µV
1 MHz38.47 µV12.87 µV4.071 µV
10 MHz61.06 µV38.47 µV12.87 µV
100 MHz64.05 µV61.06 µV38.47 µV
1 GHz64.34 µV64.05 µV61.06 µV
10 GHz64.37 µV64.34 µV64.05 µV
100 GHz64.38 µV64.37 µV64.34 µV
1 THz64.38 µV64.38 µV64.37 µV

Measured on ngspice 42 (241 of the run's 1201 frequencies, 100 per decade).

A quieter resistor is also a faster one, and on a capacitor the two effects cancel exactly.

Noise spread over frequency

Thermal noise is the random motion of charge in every resistor. Its power spectral density is the noise power in each 1 Hz slice of frequency: 4kTR in V2/Hz, where k is Boltzmann's constant and T the temperature in kelvin. It is white, the same at every frequency, and its square root in V/√Hz is the density that SPICE prints.

A capacitor across the resistor makes a low-pass filter with its corner at f-3dB = 1/(2πRC). Noise below the corner reaches the capacitor, and noise far above it is shorted away by the capacitor. The rms (root-mean-square) noise on the capacitor is the square root of the density squared, added up over every frequency. Noise sources are random, so their powers add and their voltages do not.

AC analysisDensity and running total, 10 kΩ and 100 kΩ on 1 pFAbove: the noise density on the capacitor, in V/√Hz. Below: the running total, in V rms.
  • 100 kΩ density
  • 10 kΩ density
  • 100 kΩ total
  • 10 kΩ total
10 fV/rtHz1 pV/rtHz100 pV/rtHz10 nV/rtHzDensity (V/rtHz)020 µV40 µV60 µV80 µVTotal up to f (V rms)1 Hz100 Hz10 kHz1 MHz100 MHz10 GHz1 THzFrequencyf_-3dB, 100 kΩf_-3dB, 10 kΩ10 fV/rtHz1 pV/rtHz100 pV/rtHz10 nV/rtHzDensity (V/rtHz)020 µV40 µV60 µV80 µVTotal up to f (V rms)1 Hz10 kHz100 MHz1 THzFrequencyf_-3dB, 100 kΩf_-3dB, 10 kΩ
  1. Frequency 1 kHz100 kΩ density = 40.71 nV/rtHz · 10 kΩ density = 12.87 nV/rtHz · 100 kΩ total = 1.287 µV · 10 kΩ total = 406.9 nV

    Far below both corners each density is its resistor's own: 40.71 nV/√Hz for 100 kΩ, 12.87 nV/√Hz for 10 kΩ. Ten times the resistance gives √10 times the density.

  2. Frequency 1.592 MHz100 kΩ density = 28.79 nV/rtHz · 10 kΩ density = 12.81 nV/rtHz · 100 kΩ total = 45.52 µV · 10 kΩ total = 16.22 µV

    The 100 kΩ corner, 1.592 MHz. Its running total is 45.52 µV, half of its final noise power. The 10 kΩ total is only 16.22 µV.

  3. Frequency 15.92 MHz100 kΩ density = 4.052 nV/rtHz · 10 kΩ density = 9.103 nV/rtHz · 100 kΩ total = 62.3 µV · 10 kΩ total = 45.52 µV

    The 10 kΩ corner, ten times higher at 15.92 MHz. Its total has now reached 45.52 µV too: half of the same final power.

  4. Frequency 1 GHz100 kΩ density = 64.8 pV/rtHz · 10 kΩ density = 204.9 pV/rtHz · 100 kΩ total = 64.34 µV · 10 kΩ total = 64.05 µV

    Both totals have settled at 64.37 µV. The taller curve is narrower by exactly as much as it is taller.

Read the plot as a table
Frequency100 kΩ density10 kΩ density100 kΩ total10 kΩ total
1 Hz40.71 nV/rtHz12.87 nV/rtHz0 V0 V
10 Hz40.71 nV/rtHz12.87 nV/rtHz122.1 nV38.62 nV
100 Hz40.71 nV/rtHz12.87 nV/rtHz405.1 nV128.1 nV
1 kHz40.71 nV/rtHz12.87 nV/rtHz1.287 µV406.9 nV
10 kHz40.71 nV/rtHz12.87 nV/rtHz4.071 µV1.287 µV
100 kHz40.63 nV/rtHz12.87 nV/rtHz12.87 µV4.071 µV
1 MHz34.47 nV/rtHz12.85 nV/rtHz38.47 µV12.87 µV
1.592 MHz28.79 nV/rtHz12.81 nV/rtHz45.52 µV16.22 µV
10 MHz6.399 nV/rtHz10.9 nV/rtHz61.06 µV38.47 µV
15.92 MHz4.052 nV/rtHz9.103 nV/rtHz62.3 µV45.52 µV
100 MHz647.9 pV/rtHz2.024 nV/rtHz64.05 µV61.06 µV
1 GHz64.8 pV/rtHz204.9 pV/rtHz64.34 µV64.05 µV
10 GHz6.48 pV/rtHz20.49 pV/rtHz64.37 µV64.34 µV
100 GHz648 fV/rtHz2.049 pV/rtHz64.38 µV64.37 µV
1 THz64.8 fV/rtHz204.9 fV/rtHz64.38 µV64.38 µV

Measured on ngspice 42 (241 of 1201 frequencies). rtHz is √Hz.

Read the two curves together. The larger resistor makes more noise per hertz, but its corner sits ten times lower, so it passes ten times fewer hertz. On the lower panel both running totals rise to the same 64.37 µV.

Why the resistor drops out

The step that removes R is the noise bandwidth: the width of an ideal brick-wall filter that passes the same noise power as the real one. For a single pole it is π/2 times the −3 dB frequency.

  1. Density

    The resistor gives 4kTR V2/Hz. For 10 kΩ at 27 °C that is (12.87 nV)2 per hertz.

  2. Noise bandwidth

    One pole at f-3dB = 1/(2πRC) passes noise like a brick wall of width (π/2)·f-3dB = 1/(4RC). For 10 kΩ and 1 pF: 25 MHz.

  3. Multiply

    vn2 = 4kTR · 1/(4RC) = kT/C. R cancels. For 1 pF at 300.15 K: (64.37 µV)2.

  4. Check on the simulator

    The lab prints 64.37 µV for 10 kΩ, and the hook's run gives 64.37 µV for 1 kΩ and for 100 kΩ.

The table below changes one thing at a time on the simulator. Resistance does nothing, while capacitance and temperature act exactly as √(kT/C) says they should.

Circuit√(kT/C) by handSimulated total
1 kΩ, 1 pF, 27 °C64.37 µV64.37 µV
10 kΩ, 1 pF, 27 °C64.37 µV64.37 µV
100 kΩ, 1 pF, 27 °C64.37 µV64.37 µV
10 kΩ, 0.25 pF, 27 °C128.7 µV128.7 µV
10 kΩ, 4 pF, 27 °C32.19 µV32.19 µV
10 kΩ, 1 pF, −40 °C56.74 µV56.74 µV
10 kΩ, 1 pF, 125 °C74.14 µV74.14 µV

Simulated with 100 points per decade from 1 Hz to 1 THz. The hand values use k = 1.380649 × 10−23 J/K, the constant ngspice prints as boltz.

Bits cost capacitance

Every switched-capacitor circuit and every sample-and-hold freezes this noise on its capacitor at the instant the switch opens. The frozen value is random from sample to sample, with the rms value √(kT/C). An analog-to-digital converter (ADC) with N bits over a range VFS has steps of VFS/2N, one LSB (least significant bit). A common budget keeps the sampled noise under half an LSB.

Solve √(kT/C) = LSB/2 for C to get C = kT/(LSB/2)2. Each extra bit halves the LSB, so C grows four times, and the circuit that charges it in the same time needs about four times the current.

Bits (1 V range)Half an LSBC = kT/(LSB/2)2Simulated noise with that C
81.953 mV1.086 fF1.952 mV
10488.3 µV17.38 fF488.3 µV
12122.1 µV278.1 fF122.1 µV

Each row is an RC with 100 kΩ and the capacitor shown, measured on ngspice 42. Real converters add margin for other noise.

So a lower switch resistance buys speed, which matters for settling, but it never buys lower sampled noise. Only the capacitor sets that, as the two benches below show.

A quieter switch

R1 in out 1k
C1 out 0 1p
noise v(out) V1 dec 100 1 1T

64.37 µV, the same as with 10 kΩ. The noise moved to higher frequencies.

A larger capacitor

R1 in out 10k
C1 out 0 4p
noise v(out) V1 dec 100 1 1T

32.19 µV: four times the capacitance halves the noise.

Both from the hook's run on ngspice 42.

Asked in interviews
  1. Derive kT/C noise.

    A resistor's noise 4kTR V2/Hz passes through one pole at 1/(2πRC). Its noise bandwidth is π/2 times that, 1/(4RC). Multiply: 4kTR/(4RC) = kT/C. For 1 pF at room temperature, 64.4 µV rms.

  2. Why does the resistor value not matter?

    A larger R makes more noise per hertz, and in the same proportion lowers the bandwidth that reaches the capacitor. The product is fixed. R only decides how fast the noise moves, which matters for settling.

  3. What does kT/C mean for ADC resolution and power?

    Half an LSB of noise needs C ≥ kT/(LSB/2)2. One more bit halves the LSB, so C grows four times. Driving four times the capacitance in the same time takes about four times the current.

Try it

Run it: vn is the simulated total and ktc is √(kT/C) from the same run. They agree to 0.002 %; the rest is the integration over 100 points per decade. Open Plots to see the density that vn integrates.

Now change R1 to 1k, then 100k, and predict vn before each run. Then change C1 to 4p (and 1p in the ktc line), and add .temp 125. Only the last two move the answer.

SPICEngspice 42 · simulator service
Edit the netlist, then run it
Expected measurements: vn = 6.437300e-05 ktc = 6.437404e-05

Check yourself

Predict the outputThis RC has 50 kΩ in series with 4 pF at 27 °C. The run prints its total noise in microvolts, rounded to a whole number. Type the line meas prints (format: vn_uv = 6.400000e+01).
* the noise on 4 pF behind 50 k, rounded to whole microvolts
V1 in 0 DC 0 AC 1
R1 in out 50k
C1 out 0 4p
.control
noise v(out) V1 dec 100 1 1T
dc V1 0 0.1 0.1
let one = 1+0*v(in)
let uv = floor(1e6*noise2.onoise_total+0.5)*one
meas dc vn_uv FIND uv AT=0
.endc
.end
ConceptA sampled signal on 1 pF has 64 µV of kT/C noise, twice what the spec allows. Which change brings it into spec?
ConceptWhy does the resistor's value drop out of the total noise on the capacitor?
ConceptOn the density plot, the 100 kΩ curve sits above the 10 kΩ curve at low frequency and falls off ten times earlier. What do the two curves have in common?
ConceptA 10-bit design needs 17.4 fF for its kT/C noise to stay under half an LSB. About how much does a 12-bit version of the same range need?

Remember

  • The total thermal noise on a capacitor fed through any resistor is √(kT/C): 64.37 µV rms for 1 pF at 27 °C.
  • R drops out because the density 4kTR grows with R while the noise bandwidth 1/(4RC), π/2 times f-3dB, shrinks with it.
  • To halve sampled noise, make C four times larger; each extra ADC bit costs four times the capacitance and the drive current.
  • A noise total integrates the sweep: run it well past the corner, with enough points per decade, and copy it into a dc or ac plot to measure it.