IDs and same-ID order: why responses come back in order
Say what an AXI ID names, explain from the wires alone why two responses with one ID must return in request order, name who enforces it and what it costs, and know which half of the rule a checker can see.
- Lesson
- P2.10
- Time
- 35 min
- Runs on
- Your browser
- Check
- 5 questions
A DMA engine fetched a descriptor from external memory and a status word from on-chip SRAM, both with ID 5, the only ID it used. The memory controller served the SRAM read in two cycles and the DRAM read in six, and it sent each answer the moment it had it. The engine took the first answer as the descriptor, because the first request was, and programmed itself from the status word. Nothing on the read data channel said which answer was which; both said ID 5.
All cycles
Both answers carry ID 5. Only their order tells the manager which is which.
- Cycle 1
The first read with ID 5 goes to the slow path, which needs six cycles. The manager notes: the first answer on ID 5 is this one.
- Cycle 2
The second read with ID 5 goes to the fast path.
- Cycle 4
The fast path has its data, 50, two cycles later. It may not send it: an older read with ID 5 is still open.
- Cycle 8
The slow answer, d0, leaves first and lands on the first request. The manager has no other way to pair them.
- Cycle 9
Now 50 leaves and lands on the second request. Five cycles of waiting bought the only guarantee the ID can give.
The read data channel carries the ID and nothing else that names a request. Same ID, same order: that is the whole rule.
An ID names a stream of transactions
Every AXI request carries an identifier: AWID on the write address channel, ARID on the read address channel. Every response echoes it: BID on a write response, RID on every read data beat. The width is a property of the interface, from 0 to 32 bits, and an interface with one outstanding transaction may leave the signals out.
The ID is not a serial number. A manager that needs responses in a known order gives those requests one ID. One that does not care gives them different IDs and lets the system answer in whatever order is fastest. One physical port becomes several logical ports, each in order within itself.
| Signal | Channel | What it carries |
|---|---|---|
| AWID | write address | the stream this write belongs to |
| BID | write response | the AWID of the write it answers |
| ARID | read address | the stream this read belongs to |
| RID | read data, every beat | the ARID of the read it answers |
Four signals, one idea. A response names its stream and nothing more: no address, no sequence number.
Behind an interconnect the ID grows. The interconnect appends bits that name the manager port, so two managers using ID 2 never collide at a subordinate. It strips them from BID and RID on the way back.
Why the same ID must come back in order
Look at what the read data channel carries: RID, RDATA, RRESP, RLAST. No address. No request number. If a manager has two reads open with ID 5 and a beat with RID 5 arrives, the only fact available is that it came first. So the rule has to be: responses with the same ID return in the order of their requests. Any other rule would leave the manager guessing.
The specification says it in one line: transactions with a given ID value must remain ordered, and there is no restriction between different IDs. Reusing an ID is how a manager asks for that promise; a fresh ID declines it.
In the bench the memory has two paths. Addresses from 0x4000 answer six cycles after the request, like external memory; addresses below answer in two, like on-chip SRAM. The example sends a 4-beat read to the slow path and a 2-beat read to the fast path, both with ID 5, one cycle apart. The fast read has its data by edge 6 and sends it at edge 14, after the slow read's last beat.
Who holds the fast answer
Somebody has to keep the promise. When both reads land in one subordinate, the subordinate does it: it keeps the fast data until the older read with that ID has finished. When the reads go to different subordinates, neither knows about the other, so the interconnect does it. Usually it holds the second request until every response of that ID from the other target is back.
The subordinate
Serves requests in any order it likes internally, but releases responses with one ID in request order. The bench memory does this with its slow and fast paths.
The interconnect
Holds a request whose ID still has responses outstanding from a different target. On the module's fabric the second AR with ID 5 waited ten edges, from edge 4 to edge 14, until the slow memory's last beat had left.
The manager
Can avoid the question by waiting for the first response before issuing the second request with that ID. That is the safe choice when the two reads must not be reordered and throughput does not matter.
A fabric that forgets the rule is easy to build and hard to catch. With the hold switched off, the module's fabric let the fast memory answer first. The first beat on ID 6 carried 50, and the manager booked it against the slow read of 0x8100. Every edge on the wires was legal.
What the order costs
The hold is not free. In the bench a fast read behind a slow read of the same ID gets its single beat at edge 11, seven edges after its request. The same read on its own ID is answered at edge 16, three edges after its request. The extra four edges are head-of-line blocking: the fast answer stood in line behind a slower one for no reason except the ID.
That is the trade. One ID everywhere gives a simple manager and a slow system. Many IDs give throughput and a manager that must reassemble by ID, which the next lesson builds. AXI5 adds an optional unique-ID indicator, so downstream logic can skip the tracking for a request whose ID is alone in flight.
What a checker can see
Switch the bench memory to a broken mode, mem.reorder_same_id = 1, and it answers the fast read first. With a 4-beat and a 2-beat read the checker catches it. The first beats on ID 5 are credited to the oldest open read, so RLAST arrives on beat 1 of a read whose ARLEN is 3, and the rule named is rlast.
Give both reads two beats and the same checker is silent. Every handshake is legal, every RLAST lands on the right beat, and the data is simply on the wrong request. Only something that knows the expected data can see that: a scoreboard keyed by ID, which lesson P2.11 writes. Same-ID order is a protocol rule that lives in the data.
Asked in interviews: IDs and ordering
Why must responses with the same ID return in order?
Because a response carries only the ID. A manager with two open transactions on one ID can pair the answers with the requests only by their order, so the system promises that order.
Who enforces it?
The subordinate for transactions it holds itself, the interconnect for transactions that went to different subordinates, usually by holding the later request until the earlier responses are back.
What is the ID for, then?
To let a manager issue several transactions without waiting. Different IDs may complete in any order, so fast targets are not stuck behind slow ones.
How does an interconnect keep IDs unique?
It appends bits that name the manager port to AWID and ARID, so the subordinate sees a wider ID, and strips them from BID and RID on the way back.
Can a protocol checker catch same-ID reordering?
Only when the reordered transactions differ in length, through RLAST on the wrong beat. Otherwise the wires are legal and only a data check by ID sees it.
Try it
The first pair shares ID 5: the fast read's two beats wait behind the slow read's four. The second pair uses IDs 6 and 7: the fast read answers at edge 20, before the slow read starts at edge 23. The memory is the same; only the IDs changed.
Now add mem.reorder_same_id = 1; to the setup and run again. The fast read answers first on ID 5 and the checker reports rlast three times, because the beats it credits to the 4-beat read end after two. Then make both reads 2 beats long: the checker is silent and the data sits on the wrong requests.
RUNIcarus Verilog · in your browser
Expected:
-- one ID, slow region first: the fast data waits e3 AR id=5 addr=0x4000 len=3 size=2 INCR e4 AR id=5 addr=0x100 len=1 size=2 INCR e10 R id=5 beat 0 data=0xd0 OKAY addr 0x4000 lanes 0-3 e11 R id=5 beat 1 data=0xd1 OKAY addr 0x4004 lanes 0-3 e12 R id=5 beat 2 data=0xd2 OKAY addr 0x4008 lanes 0-3 e13 R id=5 beat 3 data=0xd3 OKAY last addr 0x400c lanes 0-3 e14 R id=5 beat 0 data=0x50 OKAY addr 0x100 lanes 0-3 e15 R id=5 beat 1 data=0x51 OKAY last addr 0x104 lanes 0-3 -- two IDs: the fast data goes first e16 AR id=6 addr=0x4000 len=3 size=2 INCR e17 AR id=7 addr=0x100 len=1 size=2 INCR e20 R id=7 beat 0 data=0x50 OKAY addr 0x100 lanes 0-3 e21 R id=7 beat 1 data=0x51 OKAY last addr 0x104 lanes 0-3 e23 R id=6 beat 0 data=0xd0 OKAY addr 0x4000 lanes 0-3 e24 R id=6 beat 1 data=0xd1 OKAY addr 0x4004 lanes 0-3 e25 R id=6 beat 2 data=0xd2 OKAY addr 0x4008 lanes 0-3 e26 R id=6 beat 3 data=0xd3 OKAY last addr 0x400c lanes 0-3 checker: 0 writes, 4 reads, 0 stalled edges, 0 rules brokenRead included file: axi_pkg.sv
`timescale 1ns/1ns
// axi_pkg.sv: the arithmetic of a burst (read-only).
// Every transfer n of a burst has an address and a set of byte lanes, computed from the start
// address, the burst length, the transfer size and the burst type exactly as the AXI specification
// defines them. The memory, the manager tasks and the checker all use these functions, so they
// never disagree about where a byte lands.
package axi_pkg;
localparam logic [1:0] FIXED = 2'b00, INCR = 2'b01, WRAP = 2'b10;
localparam logic [1:0] OKAY = 2'b00, EXOKAY = 2'b01, SLVERR = 2'b10, DECERR = 2'b11;
function automatic string burst_name(input logic [1:0] b);
case (b) FIXED: return "FIXED"; INCR: return "INCR"; WRAP: return "WRAP"; default: return "RESERVED"; endcase
endfunction
function automatic string resp_name(input logic [1:0] r);
case (r) OKAY: return "OKAY"; EXOKAY: return "EXOKAY"; SLVERR: return "SLVERR"; default: return "DECERR"; endcase
endfunction
// Bytes in one transfer: 1, 2, 4, ... 128.
function automatic int bytes_of(input logic [2:0] size);
return 1 << size;
endfunction
// The address of transfer n (n counts from 0).
// transfer 0 uses the start address as given, aligned or not;
// later transfers use the start address aligned down to the transfer size, plus n transfers;
// a WRAP burst returns to its wrap boundary (the start aligned down to the whole burst) when
// it reaches the end of that window; a FIXED burst repeats the start address.
function automatic int unsigned beat_addr(input int unsigned start, input int len, input logic [2:0] size,
input logic [1:0] burst, input int n);
int unsigned nb = 1 << size;
int unsigned aligned = (start / nb) * nb;
int unsigned window = nb * (len + 1);
int unsigned boundary = (start / window) * window;
int unsigned a;
if (burst == FIXED || n == 0) return start;
a = aligned + n * nb;
if (burst == WRAP && a >= boundary + window) a = a - window;
return a;
endfunction
// The byte lanes transfer n uses on a bus of bus_bytes bytes, packed as {upper, lower}.
// Transfer 0 of an unaligned burst (and every transfer of a FIXED burst) uses only the lanes from
// its address up to the end of its aligned transfer; every other transfer uses all the lanes of
// its size.
function automatic logic [15:0] beat_lanes(input int unsigned start, input int len, input logic [2:0] size,
input logic [1:0] burst, input int n, input int bus_bytes);
int unsigned nb = 1 << size;
int unsigned a = beat_addr(start, len, size, burst, n);
int unsigned aligned = (a / nb) * nb;
int unsigned word = (a / bus_bytes) * bus_bytes;
int lower = a - word;
int upper = (n == 0 || burst == FIXED) ? (aligned + nb - 1 - word) : (lower + nb - 1);
return {upper[7:0], lower[7:0]};
endfunction
// The strobe of transfer n: a 1 for every lane it uses (bit l is lane l).
function automatic logic [63:0] beat_strb(input int unsigned start, input int len, input logic [2:0] size,
input logic [1:0] burst, input int n, input int bus_bytes);
logic [15:0] lanes = beat_lanes(start, len, size, burst, n, bus_bytes);
logic [63:0] s = 0;
for (int l = lanes[7:0]; l <= lanes[15:8]; l++) s[l] = 1'b1;
return s;
endfunction
// True when the burst crosses a 4 KB boundary (only an INCR burst can).
function automatic bit crosses_4k(input int unsigned start, input int len, input logic [2:0] size, input logic [1:0] burst);
if (burst != INCR) return 0;
return (beat_addr(start, len, size, burst, 0) / 4096) != ((beat_addr(start, len, size, burst, len) + (1 << size) - 1) / 4096);
endfunction
endpackage
Read included file: axi_mem.sv
`timescale 1ns/1ns
// axi_mem.sv: an AXI4 subordinate with a byte-addressed memory behind it (read-only in this lesson).
// It accepts requests on AW and AR, write beats on W (before or after their AW), writes the bytes a
// burst addresses using the strobes, and answers on B and R after a latency. The switches below are
// plain variables: the stimulus sets them by name (mem.reorder = 1;) before it starts.
// rd_latency, wr_latency cycles from a request (or its last write beat) to its first response
// slow_latency, slow_above addresses at or above slow_above answer after slow_latency instead
// err_above addresses at or above err_above get SLVERR (and are not written)
// reorder answer transactions with DIFFERENT IDs as soon as each is ready;
// transactions with the same ID still answer in order
// interleave interleave the read data beats of ready transactions with different IDs
// excl_on support exclusive access (one monitor per ID), else answer OKAY
// posted apply a write to the memory only when its response is sent, so a read
// that arrives between the last beat and B still sees the old bytes
// trace print every byte the memory writes
// Broken twins, each off by default: early_b (B before the last write beat and before AW),
// ignore_strobes (write every lane of the bus word), drop_hold (RDATA changes while RVALID waits
// for RREADY), reorder_same_id (a later transaction with the same ID may answer first),
// wrap_bug (a WRAP burst addressed like INCR).
module axi_mem #(parameter int DATA_W = 32, parameter int ID_W = 4, parameter int DEPTH = 65536) (
input logic aclk,
input logic aresetn,
input logic [ID_W-1:0] awid,
input logic [31:0] awaddr,
input logic [7:0] awlen,
input logic [2:0] awsize,
input logic [1:0] awburst,
input logic awlock,
input logic [3:0] awcache,
input logic [2:0] awprot,
input logic awvalid,
output logic awready,
input logic [DATA_W-1:0] wdata,
input logic [DATA_W/8-1:0] wstrb,
input logic wlast,
input logic wvalid,
output logic wready,
output logic [ID_W-1:0] bid,
output logic [1:0] bresp,
output logic bvalid,
input logic bready,
input logic [ID_W-1:0] arid,
input logic [31:0] araddr,
input logic [7:0] arlen,
input logic [2:0] arsize,
input logic [1:0] arburst,
input logic arlock,
input logic [3:0] arcache,
input logic [2:0] arprot,
input logic arvalid,
output logic arready,
output logic [ID_W-1:0] rid,
output logic [DATA_W-1:0] rdata,
output logic [1:0] rresp,
output logic rlast,
output logic rvalid,
input logic rready
);
import axi_pkg::*;
localparam int BUS = DATA_W / 8;
localparam int N = 16; // transactions in flight per direction
// ---- switches ----
int rd_latency = 2, wr_latency = 2, slow_latency = 8;
int unsigned slow_above = 32'hffff_ffff, err_above = 32'hffff_ffff;
bit reorder = 0, interleave = 0, excl_on = 0, posted = 0, trace = 0;
bit early_b = 0, ignore_strobes = 0, drop_hold = 0, reorder_same_id = 0, wrap_bug = 0;
// ---- the memory ----
logic [7:0] mem [0:DEPTH-1];
initial for (int i = 0; i < DEPTH; i++) mem[i] = 8'h00;
int cycle = -1;
int seq = 0; // every request gets a sequence number: issue order
// ---- write side: accepted AW requests (a ring) and write beats (a ring) ----
logic [ID_W-1:0] aw_id [0:N-1];
int unsigned aw_addr [0:N-1];
int aw_len [0:N-1];
logic [2:0] aw_size [0:N-1];
logic [1:0] aw_burst [0:N-1];
logic aw_lock [0:N-1];
int aw_head = 0, aw_tail = 0, aw_count = 0;
localparam int WQ = 1024;
logic [DATA_W-1:0] w_data [0:WQ-1];
logic [BUS-1:0] w_strb [0:WQ-1];
logic w_last [0:WQ-1];
int w_head = 0, w_tail = 0, w_count = 0, w_bursts = 0; // w_bursts: complete bursts in the ring
// ---- write responses waiting for their latency ----
logic b_use [0:N-1];
logic [ID_W-1:0] b_id [0:N-1];
logic [1:0] b_rsp [0:N-1];
int b_at [0:N-1], b_seq [0:N-1];
logic b_driving = 0;
logic early_done = 0; // the early_b twin answers once per burst
// posted writes: the beats of a write kept until its response goes out
logic [DATA_W-1:0] p_data [0:N-1][0:255];
logic [BUS-1:0] p_strb [0:N-1][0:255];
int unsigned p_addr [0:N-1];
int p_len [0:N-1];
logic [2:0] p_size [0:N-1];
logic [1:0] p_burst [0:N-1];
logic p_pending [0:N-1];
// ---- read side: accepted AR requests with their progress ----
logic r_use [0:N-1];
logic [ID_W-1:0] r_id [0:N-1];
int unsigned r_addr [0:N-1];
int r_len [0:N-1];
logic [2:0] r_size [0:N-1];
logic [1:0] r_burst [0:N-1];
logic r_lock [0:N-1];
int r_at [0:N-1], r_seq [0:N-1], r_beat [0:N-1], r_served [0:N-1];
int r_cur = -1; // the transaction whose beat is on the wires
logic r_driving = 0;
// ---- exclusive monitors, one per ID ----
logic mon_use [0:(1<<ID_W)-1];
int unsigned mon_addr [0:(1<<ID_W)-1];
int unsigned mon_bytes [0:(1<<ID_W)-1];
initial begin
for (int i = 0; i < N; i++) begin b_use[i] = 0; r_use[i] = 0; p_pending[i] = 0; end
for (int i = 0; i < (1 << ID_W); i++) mon_use[i] = 0;
awready = 0; wready = 0; arready = 0; bvalid = 0; rvalid = 0; bid = 0; bresp = 0; rid = 0; rresp = 0; rlast = 0; rdata = 0;
end
function automatic int latency_of(input int unsigned a, input int base);
return (a >= slow_above) ? slow_latency : base;
endfunction
function automatic logic [1:0] burst_used(input logic [1:0] b);
return (wrap_bug && b == WRAP) ? INCR : b;
endfunction
// ---- selection policies ----
// The oldest of all pending entries, or the oldest of its ID: the in-order rule of the protocol.
function automatic bit b_oldest(input int i, input bit same_id_only);
for (int j = 0; j < N; j++)
if (b_use[j] && j != i && b_seq[j] < b_seq[i] && (!same_id_only || b_id[j] == b_id[i])) return 0;
return 1;
endfunction
function automatic bit r_oldest(input int i, input bit same_id_only);
for (int j = 0; j < N; j++)
if (r_use[j] && j != i && r_seq[j] < r_seq[i] && (!same_id_only || r_id[j] == r_id[i])) return 0;
return 1;
endfunction
function automatic bit b_eligible(input int i);
if (!b_use[i] || b_at[i] > cycle) return 0;
if (!reorder) return b_oldest(i, 0);
return reorder_same_id ? 1 : b_oldest(i, 1);
endfunction
function automatic bit r_eligible(input int i);
if (!r_use[i] || r_at[i] > cycle) return 0;
if (!reorder) return r_oldest(i, 0);
return reorder_same_id ? 1 : r_oldest(i, 1);
endfunction
function automatic int free_b();
for (int i = 0; i < N; i++) if (!b_use[i]) return i;
return -1;
endfunction
function automatic int free_r();
for (int i = 0; i < N; i++) if (!r_use[i]) return i;
return -1;
endfunction
function automatic int pick_b();
int best = -1;
for (int i = 0; i < N; i++) if (b_eligible(i) && (best < 0 || b_seq[i] < b_seq[best])) best = i;
return best;
endfunction
function automatic int pick_r();
int best = -1;
for (int i = 0; i < N; i++) if (r_eligible(i)) begin
if (best < 0) best = i;
else if (interleave ? (r_served[i] < r_served[best]) : (r_seq[i] < r_seq[best])) best = i;
end
return best;
endfunction
// ---- the bytes of one read beat, as the bus word that holds them ----
function automatic logic [DATA_W-1:0] read_word(input int unsigned a);
logic [DATA_W-1:0] d = 0;
int unsigned word = (a / BUS) * BUS;
for (int l = 0; l < BUS; l++) d[8*l +: 8] = (word + l < DEPTH) ? mem[word + l] : 8'h00;
return d;
endfunction
// ---- the write of one complete burst into the memory ----
task automatic write_burst(input int e);
logic [1:0] rsp = OKAY;
logic do_write = 1, ended = 0;
int unsigned a, word;
logic [15:0] lanes;
int n = 0, slot;
int unsigned total = (1 << aw_size[e]) * (aw_len[e] + 1);
slot = free_b();
if (aw_lock[e] && excl_on) begin
if (mon_use[aw_id[e]] && mon_addr[aw_id[e]] == aw_addr[e]) begin
rsp = EXOKAY;
$display("mem e%0d: exclusive write id=%0d at 0x%0h: the monitor matched, EXOKAY", cycle, aw_id[e], aw_addr[e]);
end else begin
do_write = 0;
$display("mem e%0d: exclusive write id=%0d at 0x%0h: no monitor, OKAY and nothing written", cycle, aw_id[e], aw_addr[e]);
end
end
while (!ended && n <= aw_len[e]) begin
a = beat_addr(aw_addr[e], aw_len[e], aw_size[e], burst_used(aw_burst[e]), n);
lanes = beat_lanes(aw_addr[e], aw_len[e], aw_size[e], burst_used(aw_burst[e]), n, BUS);
word = (a / BUS) * BUS;
if (a >= err_above) rsp = SLVERR;
else if (do_write && posted && slot >= 0) begin
p_data[slot][n] = w_data[w_head]; p_strb[slot][n] = w_strb[w_head];
end else if (do_write) begin
for (int l = 0; l < BUS; l++)
if ((w_strb[w_head][l] || ignore_strobes) && word + l < DEPTH) begin
mem[word + l] = w_data[w_head][8*l +: 8];
if (trace) $display("mem e%0d: beat %0d writes 0x%02h to 0x%0h (lane %0d)", cycle, n, w_data[w_head][8*l +: 8], word + l, l);
end
end
ended = w_last[w_head]; // a burst ends at its WLAST, whatever AWLEN said
w_head = (w_head + 1) % WQ; w_count = w_count - 1;
n = n + 1;
end
while (!ended) begin // beats past AWLEN (a broken manager) are dropped
ended = w_last[w_head];
w_head = (w_head + 1) % WQ; w_count = w_count - 1;
end
// A write clears every monitor that watches a byte it touched.
if (do_write)
for (int i = 0; i < (1 << ID_W); i++)
if (mon_use[i] && mon_addr[i] < aw_addr[e] + total && aw_addr[e] < mon_addr[i] + mon_bytes[i]) mon_use[i] = 0;
if (slot >= 0) begin
b_use[slot] = 1; b_id[slot] = aw_id[e]; b_rsp[slot] = rsp; b_seq[slot] = seq; seq = seq + 1;
b_at[slot] = cycle + latency_of(aw_addr[e], wr_latency);
if (posted && do_write) begin
p_pending[slot] = 1; p_addr[slot] = aw_addr[e]; p_len[slot] = n - 1; p_size[slot] = aw_size[e]; p_burst[slot] = aw_burst[e];
end
end
endtask
// A posted write reaches the memory when its response goes out.
task automatic apply_posted(input int i);
int unsigned a, word;
for (int n = 0; n <= p_len[i]; n++) begin
a = beat_addr(p_addr[i], p_len[i], p_size[i], burst_used(p_burst[i]), n);
word = (a / BUS) * BUS;
if (a < err_above)
for (int l = 0; l < BUS; l++)
if ((p_strb[i][n][l] || ignore_strobes) && word + l < DEPTH) begin
mem[word + l] = p_data[i][n][8*l +: 8];
if (trace) $display("mem e%0d: posted beat %0d writes 0x%02h to 0x%0h (lane %0d)", cycle, n, p_data[i][n][8*l +: 8], word + l, l);
end
end
p_pending[i] = 0;
endtask
int pick, extra;
always @(posedge aclk) begin
cycle = cycle + 1;
if (!aresetn) begin
aw_head = 0; aw_tail = 0; aw_count = 0; w_head = 0; w_tail = 0; w_count = 0; w_bursts = 0;
for (int i = 0; i < N; i++) begin b_use[i] = 0; r_use[i] = 0; end
b_driving = 0; r_driving = 0; r_cur = -1;
awready <= 0; wready <= 0; arready <= 0; bvalid <= 0; rvalid <= 0;
end else begin
// -- AW: take a request while there is room --
if (awvalid && awready) begin
aw_id[aw_tail] = awid; aw_addr[aw_tail] = awaddr; aw_len[aw_tail] = awlen; aw_size[aw_tail] = awsize;
aw_burst[aw_tail] = awburst; aw_lock[aw_tail] = awlock;
aw_tail = (aw_tail + 1) % N; aw_count = aw_count + 1;
end
// -- W: take a beat while there is room --
if (wvalid && wready) begin
w_data[w_tail] = wdata; w_strb[w_tail] = wstrb; w_last[w_tail] = wlast;
w_tail = (w_tail + 1) % WQ; w_count = w_count + 1;
if (wlast) w_bursts = w_bursts + 1;
end
// -- a complete burst with its request: write it and schedule B --
if (aw_count > 0 && w_bursts > 0) begin
write_burst(aw_head);
aw_head = (aw_head + 1) % N; aw_count = aw_count - 1; w_bursts = w_bursts - 1;
early_done = 0;
end else if (early_b && !early_done && w_count > 0 && w_bursts == 0) begin
// The broken twin: a response as soon as the first write beat arrived, before WLAST and,
// when the data came first, before the address.
pick = free_b();
if (pick >= 0) begin
b_use[pick] = 1; b_id[pick] = (aw_count > 0) ? aw_id[aw_head] : awid; b_rsp[pick] = OKAY; b_seq[pick] = seq; seq = seq + 1; b_at[pick] = cycle;
early_done = 1;
end
end
// -- B: finish a handshake, then put the next response on the wires --
if (b_driving && bready) b_driving = 0;
if (!b_driving) begin
pick = pick_b();
if (pick >= 0) begin
if (p_pending[pick]) apply_posted(pick);
b_driving = 1; bid <= b_id[pick]; bresp <= b_rsp[pick]; b_use[pick] = 0;
end
end
bvalid <= b_driving;
// -- AR: take a request while there is room --
if (arvalid && arready) begin
pick = free_r();
if (pick >= 0) begin
r_use[pick] = 1; r_id[pick] = arid; r_addr[pick] = araddr; r_len[pick] = arlen; r_size[pick] = arsize; r_burst[pick] = arburst;
r_lock[pick] = arlock; r_beat[pick] = 0; r_seq[pick] = seq; seq = seq + 1; r_served[pick] = -1;
r_at[pick] = cycle + latency_of(araddr, rd_latency);
if (arlock && excl_on) begin
mon_use[arid] = 1; mon_addr[arid] = araddr; mon_bytes[arid] = (1 << arsize) * (arlen + 1);
$display("mem e%0d: exclusive read id=%0d at 0x%0h: monitor set", cycle, arid, araddr);
end
end
end
// -- R: finish a handshake, then put the next beat on the wires --
if (r_driving && !rready && drop_hold) rdata <= rdata + 1; // the broken twin: data not held
if (r_driving && rready) begin
r_driving = 0;
if (r_beat[r_cur] > r_len[r_cur]) begin r_use[r_cur] = 0; r_cur = -1; end
else if (interleave) r_cur = -1;
end
if (!r_driving) begin
pick = (r_cur >= 0) ? r_cur : pick_r();
if (pick >= 0) begin
r_cur = pick; r_driving = 1; r_served[pick] = cycle;
extra = r_beat[pick];
rid <= r_id[pick];
rdata <= read_word(beat_addr(r_addr[pick], r_len[pick], r_size[pick], burst_used(r_burst[pick]), extra));
rresp <= (beat_addr(r_addr[pick], r_len[pick], r_size[pick], burst_used(r_burst[pick]), extra) >= err_above) ? SLVERR
: ((r_lock[pick] && excl_on) ? EXOKAY : OKAY);
rlast <= (extra == r_len[pick]);
r_beat[pick] = extra + 1;
end
end
rvalid <= r_driving;
awready <= (aw_count < N - 1);
wready <= (w_count < WQ - 2);
arready <= 1;
end
end
endmodule
Read included file: axi_checker.sv
`timescale 1ns/1ns
// axi_checker.sv: the rules of an AXI4 interface, checked at every rising edge (read-only).
// Each broken rule is named with the channel and the edge where it was seen:
// reset a VALID is 1 while reset is active;
// hold a VALID dropped before its READY: the offer was withdrawn;
// stable a channel's payload changed while its offer waited;
// known a payload is x while its VALID is 1;
// len a FIXED or WRAP burst longer than 16 beats;
// wrap a WRAP burst whose length is not 2, 4, 8 or 16 beats or whose address is not aligned;
// boundary a burst that crosses a 4 KB boundary;
// size a transfer wider than the data bus;
// strobe a write strobe on a lane the beat does not address;
// wlast WLAST on the wrong beat (not AWLEN), or missing after it;
// rlast RLAST on the wrong beat of the oldest read with that ID, or missing after it;
// border BVALID before any outstanding write has its last beat, or before its AW;
// bid, rid a response ID with no outstanding request of that ID;
// exokay EXOKAY for a request that was not exclusive;
// exclusive an exclusive request whose bytes are not a power of two up to 128, or not aligned to them.
// The rules no checker can see on the wires (VALID must not wait for READY; same-ID responses
// in the order of their requests) are checked by the data the tasks compare (lessons P2.2, P2.10).
module axi_checker #(parameter int DATA_W = 32, parameter int ID_W = 4) (
input logic aclk,
input logic aresetn,
input logic [ID_W-1:0] awid,
input logic [31:0] awaddr,
input logic [7:0] awlen,
input logic [2:0] awsize,
input logic [1:0] awburst,
input logic awlock,
input logic awvalid,
input logic awready,
input logic [DATA_W-1:0] wdata,
input logic [DATA_W/8-1:0] wstrb,
input logic wlast,
input logic wvalid,
input logic wready,
input logic [ID_W-1:0] bid,
input logic [1:0] bresp,
input logic bvalid,
input logic bready,
input logic [ID_W-1:0] arid,
input logic [31:0] araddr,
input logic [7:0] arlen,
input logic [2:0] arsize,
input logic [1:0] arburst,
input logic arlock,
input logic arvalid,
input logic arready,
input logic [ID_W-1:0] rid,
input logic [DATA_W-1:0] rdata,
input logic [1:0] rresp,
input logic rlast,
input logic rvalid,
input logic rready
);
import axi_pkg::*;
localparam int BUS = DATA_W / 8;
localparam int Q = 64;
int cycle = -1, writes = 0, reads = 0, stalls = 0, broken = 0;
logic [DATA_W-1:0] used;
function void report(input string rule, input string what);
broken++;
$display("RULE %s broken at edge %0d: %s", rule, cycle, what);
endfunction
// Previous values of every channel, for hold and stable.
logic p_awv = 0, p_awr = 0, p_wv = 0, p_wr = 0, p_bv = 0, p_br = 0, p_arv = 0, p_arr = 0, p_rv = 0, p_rr = 0;
logic [31:0] p_awaddr, p_araddr;
logic [7:0] p_awlen, p_arlen;
logic [2:0] p_awsize, p_arsize;
logic [1:0] p_awburst, p_arburst, p_bresp, p_rresp;
logic [ID_W-1:0] p_awid, p_arid, p_bid, p_rid;
logic [DATA_W-1:0] p_wdata, p_rdata;
logic [BUS-1:0] p_wstrb;
logic p_wlast, p_rlast, p_awlock, p_arlock;
// Write requests in order (AXI4 write data follows the order of the addresses).
int unsigned q_addr [0:Q-1];
int q_len [0:Q-1];
logic [2:0] q_size [0:Q-1];
logic [1:0] q_burst [0:Q-1];
int aw_n = 0; // requests accepted
int wb_n = 0; // write bursts started
int wb_done = 0; // write bursts ended (WLAST seen)
int w_beat = 0; // beats so far in the current burst
int b_n = 0; // responses given
// Beats recorded for bursts that ran ahead of their AW: strobes and count, checked when AW arrives.
logic [BUS-1:0] rec_strb [0:Q-1][0:255];
int rec_beats [0:Q-1];
logic rec_open [0:Q-1];
// Outstanding requests per ID, and the read requests per ID in order.
int aw_out [0:(1<<ID_W)-1], ar_out [0:(1<<ID_W)-1], aw_excl [0:(1<<ID_W)-1], ar_excl [0:(1<<ID_W)-1];
int rq_len [0:(1<<ID_W)-1][0:15];
int rq_head [0:(1<<ID_W)-1], rq_tail [0:(1<<ID_W)-1], r_beat [0:(1<<ID_W)-1];
initial for (int i = 0; i < (1 << ID_W); i++) begin aw_out[i] = 0; ar_out[i] = 0; aw_excl[i] = 0; ar_excl[i] = 0; rq_head[i] = 0; rq_tail[i] = 0; r_beat[i] = 0; end
initial for (int i = 0; i < Q; i++) begin rec_beats[i] = 0; rec_open[i] = 0; end
function automatic bit pow2_le128(input int unsigned n);
return (n == 1 || n == 2 || n == 4 || n == 8 || n == 16 || n == 32 || n == 64 || n == 128);
endfunction
task automatic check_request(input string ch, input int unsigned addr, input int len, input logic [2:0] size, input logic [1:0] burst, input logic lock);
int unsigned bytes = (1 << size) * (len + 1);
if ((burst == FIXED || burst == WRAP) && len > 15) report("len", $sformatf("%s: a %s burst of %0d beats (16 at most)", ch, burst_name(burst), len + 1));
if (burst == WRAP && !(len == 1 || len == 3 || len == 7 || len == 15)) report("wrap", $sformatf("%s: a WRAP burst of %0d beats (2, 4, 8 or 16)", ch, len + 1));
if (burst == WRAP && (addr % (1 << size)) != 0) report("wrap", $sformatf("%s: WRAP burst at 0x%0h is not aligned to its %0d-byte transfers", ch, addr, 1 << size));
if (burst == 2'b11) report("len", $sformatf("%s: burst type 2'b11 is reserved", ch));
if ((1 << size) > BUS) report("size", $sformatf("%s: %0d-byte transfers on a %0d-byte bus", ch, 1 << size, BUS));
if (crosses_4k(addr, len, size, burst)) report("boundary", $sformatf("%s: burst at 0x%0h, %0d beats of %0d bytes, crosses a 4 KB boundary", ch, addr, len + 1, 1 << size));
if (lock && (!pow2_le128(bytes) || (addr % bytes) != 0)) report("exclusive", $sformatf("%s: exclusive access of %0d bytes at 0x%0h (a power of two up to 128, aligned)", ch, bytes, addr));
endtask
task automatic check_strobe(input int k, input int n, input logic [BUS-1:0] strb);
logic [63:0] allowed = beat_strb(q_addr[k % Q], q_len[k % Q], q_size[k % Q], q_burst[k % Q], n, BUS);
if ((strb & ~allowed[BUS-1:0]) != 0)
report("strobe", $sformatf("W beat %0d of write %0d: strobe %b on lanes outside %b", n, k, strb, allowed[BUS-1:0]));
endtask
always @(posedge aclk) begin
cycle++;
if (!aresetn) begin
if (awvalid === 1 || wvalid === 1 || arvalid === 1) report("reset", "a manager VALID is 1 during reset");
if (bvalid === 1 || rvalid === 1) report("reset", "a subordinate VALID is 1 during reset");
end else begin
// hold, stable and known, per channel
if (p_awv && !p_awr && awvalid !== 1) report("hold", "AWVALID dropped before AWREADY");
if (p_awv && !p_awr && awvalid === 1 && (awaddr !== p_awaddr || awlen !== p_awlen || awsize !== p_awsize || awburst !== p_awburst || awid !== p_awid || awlock !== p_awlock)) report("stable", "AW payload changed while the request waited");
if (p_wv && !p_wr && wvalid !== 1) report("hold", "WVALID dropped before WREADY");
if (p_wv && !p_wr && wvalid === 1 && (wdata !== p_wdata || wstrb !== p_wstrb || wlast !== p_wlast)) report("stable", "W payload changed while the beat waited");
if (p_bv && !p_br && bvalid !== 1) report("hold", "BVALID dropped before BREADY");
if (p_bv && !p_br && bvalid === 1 && (bresp !== p_bresp || bid !== p_bid)) report("stable", "B payload changed while the response waited");
if (p_arv && !p_arr && arvalid !== 1) report("hold", "ARVALID dropped before ARREADY");
if (p_arv && !p_arr && arvalid === 1 && (araddr !== p_araddr || arlen !== p_arlen || arsize !== p_arsize || arburst !== p_arburst || arid !== p_arid || arlock !== p_arlock)) report("stable", "AR payload changed while the request waited");
if (p_rv && !p_rr && rvalid !== 1) report("hold", "RVALID dropped before RREADY");
if (p_rv && !p_rr && rvalid === 1 && (rdata !== p_rdata || rresp !== p_rresp || rid !== p_rid || rlast !== p_rlast)) report("stable", "R payload changed while the beat waited");
if (awvalid === 1 && ($isunknown(awaddr) || $isunknown(awlen) || $isunknown(awsize) || $isunknown(awburst) || $isunknown(awid))) report("known", "AW payload is x while AWVALID is 1");
if (wvalid === 1 && ($isunknown(wstrb) || $isunknown(wlast))) report("known", "W strobe or last is x while WVALID is 1");
else if (wvalid === 1) begin
used = '0;
for (int l = 0; l < BUS; l++) if (wstrb[l] === 1) used[8*l +: 8] = 8'hff;
if ($isunknown(wdata & used)) report("known", "W data is x on a strobed lane while WVALID is 1");
end
if (arvalid === 1 && ($isunknown(araddr) || $isunknown(arlen) || $isunknown(arsize) || $isunknown(arburst) || $isunknown(arid))) report("known", "AR payload is x while ARVALID is 1");
if (bvalid === 1 && ($isunknown(bresp) || $isunknown(bid))) report("known", "B payload is x while BVALID is 1");
if (rvalid === 1 && ($isunknown(rresp) || $isunknown(rid) || $isunknown(rlast))) report("known", "R payload is x while RVALID is 1");
if ((awvalid === 1 && awready !== 1) || (wvalid === 1 && wready !== 1) || (arvalid === 1 && arready !== 1) ||
(bvalid === 1 && bready !== 1) || (rvalid === 1 && rready !== 1)) stalls++;
// AW accepted
if (awvalid === 1 && awready === 1) begin
check_request("AW", awaddr, awlen, awsize, awburst, awlock);
q_addr[aw_n % Q] = awaddr; q_len[aw_n % Q] = awlen; q_size[aw_n % Q] = awsize; q_burst[aw_n % Q] = awburst;
aw_out[awid]++; if (awlock) aw_excl[awid]++;
// beats of this write that arrived before its address: check them now
if (rec_beats[aw_n % Q] > 0) begin
for (int n = 0; n < rec_beats[aw_n % Q]; n++) check_strobe(aw_n, n, rec_strb[aw_n % Q][n]);
if (!rec_open[aw_n % Q] && rec_beats[aw_n % Q] != awlen + 1)
report("wlast", $sformatf("write %0d sent %0d beats before its AW said AWLEN=%0d", aw_n, rec_beats[aw_n % Q], awlen));
if (!rec_open[aw_n % Q]) rec_beats[aw_n % Q] = 0;
end
aw_n++;
end
// W beat accepted
if (wvalid === 1 && wready === 1) begin
if (w_beat == 0) begin wb_n++; rec_beats[(wb_n - 1) % Q] = 0; rec_open[(wb_n - 1) % Q] = 1; end
if (wb_n <= aw_n) begin
check_strobe(wb_n - 1, w_beat, wstrb);
if (wlast === 1 && w_beat != q_len[(wb_n - 1) % Q]) report("wlast", $sformatf("WLAST on beat %0d of write %0d, AWLEN=%0d", w_beat, wb_n - 1, q_len[(wb_n - 1) % Q]));
if (wlast !== 1 && w_beat == q_len[(wb_n - 1) % Q]) report("wlast", $sformatf("beat %0d of write %0d is AWLEN=%0d but WLAST is 0", w_beat, wb_n - 1, q_len[(wb_n - 1) % Q]));
end else begin
rec_strb[(wb_n - 1) % Q][w_beat] = wstrb;
end
rec_beats[(wb_n - 1) % Q] = w_beat + 1;
w_beat++;
if (wlast === 1) begin w_beat = 0; wb_done++; rec_open[(wb_n - 1) % Q] = 0; if (wb_n <= aw_n) rec_beats[(wb_n - 1) % Q] = 0; end
end
// B offered or accepted
if (bvalid === 1 && !p_bv) begin
if (b_n >= aw_n && b_n >= wb_done) report("border", "BVALID with no write to answer: neither an AW nor a WLAST is outstanding");
else if (b_n >= wb_done) report("border", "BVALID before the last beat of the write it answers");
else if (b_n >= aw_n) report("border", "BVALID before the AW of the write it answers was accepted");
end
if (bvalid === 1 && bready === 1) begin
if (aw_out[bid] == 0) report("bid", $sformatf("B with id %0d, which has no outstanding write", bid));
else begin
aw_out[bid]--; writes++;
if (bresp === EXOKAY && aw_excl[bid] == 0) report("exokay", $sformatf("EXOKAY for write id %0d, which was not exclusive", bid));
if (aw_excl[bid] > 0 && aw_excl[bid] > aw_out[bid]) aw_excl[bid] = aw_out[bid];
end
b_n++;
end
// AR accepted
if (arvalid === 1 && arready === 1) begin
check_request("AR", araddr, arlen, arsize, arburst, arlock);
rq_len[arid][rq_tail[arid]] = arlen; rq_tail[arid] = (rq_tail[arid] + 1) % 16;
ar_out[arid]++; if (arlock) ar_excl[arid]++;
end
// R beat accepted
if (rvalid === 1 && rready === 1) begin
if (ar_out[rid] == 0) report("rid", $sformatf("R with id %0d, which has no outstanding read", rid));
else begin
if (rlast === 1 && r_beat[rid] != rq_len[rid][rq_head[rid]])
report("rlast", $sformatf("RLAST on beat %0d of the oldest read with id %0d, whose ARLEN is %0d", r_beat[rid], rid, rq_len[rid][rq_head[rid]]));
if (rlast !== 1 && r_beat[rid] == rq_len[rid][rq_head[rid]])
report("rlast", $sformatf("beat %0d of the oldest read with id %0d is its ARLEN but RLAST is 0", r_beat[rid], rid));
if (rresp === EXOKAY && ar_excl[rid] == 0) report("exokay", $sformatf("EXOKAY for read id %0d, which was not exclusive", rid));
r_beat[rid]++;
if (rlast === 1) begin
r_beat[rid] = 0; rq_head[rid] = (rq_head[rid] + 1) % 16; ar_out[rid]--; reads++;
if (ar_excl[rid] > ar_out[rid]) ar_excl[rid] = ar_out[rid];
end
end
end
end
p_awv = (awvalid === 1); p_awr = (awready === 1); p_wv = (wvalid === 1); p_wr = (wready === 1);
p_bv = (bvalid === 1); p_br = (bready === 1); p_arv = (arvalid === 1); p_arr = (arready === 1);
p_rv = (rvalid === 1); p_rr = (rready === 1);
p_awaddr = awaddr; p_awlen = awlen; p_awsize = awsize; p_awburst = awburst; p_awid = awid; p_awlock = awlock;
p_wdata = wdata; p_wstrb = wstrb; p_wlast = wlast; p_bresp = bresp; p_bid = bid;
p_araddr = araddr; p_arlen = arlen; p_arsize = arsize; p_arburst = arburst; p_arid = arid; p_arlock = arlock;
p_rdata = rdata; p_rresp = rresp; p_rid = rid; p_rlast = rlast;
end
final $display("checker: %0d writes, %0d reads, %0d stalled edges, %0d rules broken", writes, reads, stalls, broken);
endmodule
Read included file: axi_tasks.svh
// axi_tasks.svh: the manager side of the bench, as tasks for the stimulus (read-only).
// Data for a write burst goes in wd[0], wd[1], ... (one entry per beat, the lowest byte at the
// lowest address); the data of a read comes back in rd[0], rd[1], ... with its responses in rr[].
// Every task prints the beat log: one line per handshake, with the edge where it happened.
// `cycle` counts rising edges from 0.
int cycle = -1;
always @(posedge aclk) cycle = cycle + 1;
logic [63:0] wd [0:255];
logic [63:0] rd [0:255];
logic [1:0] rr [0:255];
logic [63:0] rdq [0:15][0:255]; // read data per ID, for reads collected out of order
logic [1:0] rrq [0:15][0:255];
int rdn [0:15]; // beats received per ID
logic [1:0] last_bresp = 0;
int last_beats = 0;
// What the task is driving right now, for the waveform scenes: the address and lanes of the beat.
int unsigned beat_a = 0;
logic [7:0] beat_m = 0;
// quiet = 1 silences the beat log (a predict item can then ask for a dump line instead).
bit quiet = 0;
// Strobe override: when strb_force is 1, every write beat uses strb_val as it is.
bit strb_force = 0;
logic [7:0] strb_val = 8'hff;
// Outstanding read requests per ID, so the tasks know the lanes of the beats that come back.
int unsigned arq_addr [0:15][0:7];
int arq_len [0:15][0:7];
logic [2:0] arq_size [0:15][0:7];
logic [1:0] arq_burst [0:15][0:7];
int arq_head [0:15], arq_tail [0:15];
initial for (int i = 0; i < 16; i++) begin arq_head[i] = 0; arq_tail[i] = 0; rdn[i] = 0; end
// READY patterns for the response channels: bit (cycle % 16) of the pattern drives the signal.
bit rpat_on = 0, bpat_on = 0;
logic [15:0] rpat = 16'hffff, bpat = 16'hffff;
always @(posedge aclk) begin
#1;
if (rpat_on) rready = rpat[cycle % 16];
if (bpat_on) bready = bpat[cycle % 16];
end
// A text waveform for the lesson's trace blocks: with watch = 1, one line per rising edge with the
// values sampled at that edge (cycle k of a trace is what edge k sees).
bit watch = 0;
int wave_edge = -1;
always @(posedge aclk) begin
wave_edge = wave_edge + 1;
if (watch) $display("wave e%0d: aw=%b%b w=%b%b b=%b%b ar=%b%b r=%b%b awaddr=%h wdata=%h wstrb=%b wlast=%b bid=%h bresp=%b araddr=%h rid=%h rdata=%h rresp=%b rlast=%b",
wave_edge, awvalid, awready, wvalid, wready, bvalid, bready, arvalid, arready, rvalid, rready,
awaddr, wdata, wstrb, wlast, bid, bresp, araddr, rid, rdata, rresp, rlast);
end
// Drive RREADY (ch = 0) or BREADY (ch = 1) from a 16-bit pattern; 16'hffff restores always ready.
task automatic ready_pattern(input int ch, input logic [15:0] pat);
if (ch == 0) begin rpat = pat; rpat_on = 1; rready = pat[cycle % 16]; end
else begin bpat = pat; bpat_on = 1; bready = pat[cycle % 16]; end
endtask
// The write address channel: offer the request and hold it until it is taken.
task automatic aw_issue(input logic [ID_W-1:0] id, input int unsigned addr, input int len, input logic [2:0] size,
input logic [1:0] burst, input logic lock = 0);
awid = id; awaddr = addr; awlen = len[7:0]; awsize = size; awburst = burst; awlock = lock; awvalid = 1;
do @(posedge aclk); while (!awready);
#1 if (!quiet) $display("e%0d AW id=%0d addr=0x%0h len=%0d size=%0d %0s%0s", cycle, id, addr, len, size, burst_name(burst), lock ? " exclusive" : "");
awvalid = 0; awaddr = 'x; awlen = 'x; awsize = 'x; awburst = 'x; awid = 'x; awlock = 0;
endtask
// The write data channel: the beats of one burst from wd[first..], each placed in its lanes.
task automatic w_burst(input int unsigned addr, input int len, input logic [2:0] size, input logic [1:0] burst, input int first = 0);
logic [15:0] lanes;
for (int n = 0; n <= len; n++) begin
lanes = beat_lanes(addr, len, size, burst, n, BUS_BYTES);
beat_a = beat_addr(addr, len, size, burst, n);
beat_m = strb_force ? strb_val : beat_strb(addr, len, size, burst, n, BUS_BYTES);
wdata = wd[first + n] << (8 * lanes[7:0]);
wstrb = beat_m[BUS_BYTES-1:0];
wlast = (n == len);
wvalid = 1;
do @(posedge aclk); while (!wready);
#1 if (!quiet) $display("e%0d W beat %0d data=0x%0h strb=%b last=%0d addr 0x%0h lanes %0d-%0d", cycle, n, wdata, wstrb, wlast, beat_a, lanes[7:0], lanes[15:8]);
end
wvalid = 0; wdata = 'x; wstrb = 'x; wlast = 0; beat_m = 0;
endtask
// Wait for the write response of one transaction with this ID.
task automatic b_wait(input logic [ID_W-1:0] id);
do @(posedge aclk); while (!(bvalid && bready && bid == id));
last_bresp = bresp; // sampled at the edge, before the subordinate moves on
#1 if (!quiet) $display("e%0d B id=%0d %0s", cycle, id, resp_name(last_bresp));
endtask
// A complete write. order 0 offers the address, then the first beat one cycle later whether or
// not the address has been taken yet (a manager must never make WVALID wait for AWREADY); 1 offers
// the beats first and the address after beat 0; 2 offers the address and beat 0 in the same cycle.
// Returns after B, with the response in last_bresp.
task automatic axi_write(input logic [ID_W-1:0] id, input int unsigned addr, input int len, input logic [2:0] size,
input logic [1:0] burst, input int order = 0, input logic lock = 0);
case (order)
1: fork
w_burst(addr, len, size, burst);
begin @(posedge aclk); #1 aw_issue(id, addr, len, size, burst, lock); end
join
2: fork
aw_issue(id, addr, len, size, burst, lock);
w_burst(addr, len, size, burst);
join
default: fork
aw_issue(id, addr, len, size, burst, lock);
begin @(posedge aclk); #1 w_burst(addr, len, size, burst); end
join
endcase
b_wait(id);
endtask
// The read address channel: offer the request and remember it for the beats that come back.
task automatic ar_issue(input logic [ID_W-1:0] id, input int unsigned addr, input int len, input logic [2:0] size,
input logic [1:0] burst, input logic lock = 0);
arq_addr[id][arq_tail[id]] = addr; arq_len[id][arq_tail[id]] = len; arq_size[id][arq_tail[id]] = size;
arq_burst[id][arq_tail[id]] = burst; arq_tail[id] = (arq_tail[id] + 1) % 8;
arid = id; araddr = addr; arlen = len[7:0]; arsize = size; arburst = burst; arlock = lock; arvalid = 1;
do @(posedge aclk); while (!arready);
#1 if (!quiet) $display("e%0d AR id=%0d addr=0x%0h len=%0d size=%0d %0s%0s", cycle, id, addr, len, size, burst_name(burst), lock ? " exclusive" : "");
arvalid = 0; araddr = 'x; arlen = 'x; arsize = 'x; arburst = 'x; arid = 'x; arlock = 0;
endtask
// Collect read beats until n transactions have ended (their RLAST). Each beat lands in rdq[rid][k]
// with only the bytes of the transfer (lane-shifted down), and rd[] holds the last transaction.
task automatic r_collect(input int n);
int done = 0, h;
logic [15:0] lanes;
logic [63:0] bytes;
logic [ID_W-1:0] id;
logic [DATA_W-1:0] data;
logic [1:0] resp;
logic last;
while (done < n) begin
do @(posedge aclk); while (!(rvalid && rready));
id = rid; data = rdata; resp = rresp; last = rlast; // sampled at the edge, before the subordinate moves on
h = arq_head[id];
lanes = beat_lanes(arq_addr[id][h], arq_len[id][h], arq_size[id][h], arq_burst[id][h], rdn[id], BUS_BYTES);
beat_a = beat_addr(arq_addr[id][h], arq_len[id][h], arq_size[id][h], arq_burst[id][h], rdn[id]);
beat_m = beat_strb(arq_addr[id][h], arq_len[id][h], arq_size[id][h], arq_burst[id][h], rdn[id], BUS_BYTES);
bytes = (data >> (8 * lanes[7:0])) & ((64'h1 << (8 * (lanes[15:8] - lanes[7:0] + 1))) - 1);
rdq[id][rdn[id]] = bytes; rrq[id][rdn[id]] = resp;
#1 if (!quiet) $display("e%0d R id=%0d beat %0d data=0x%0h %0s%0s addr 0x%0h lanes %0d-%0d", cycle, id, rdn[id], bytes, resp_name(resp),
last ? " last" : "", beat_a, lanes[7:0], lanes[15:8]);
rdn[id] = rdn[id] + 1;
if (last) begin
for (int k = 0; k < rdn[id]; k++) begin rd[k] = rdq[id][k]; rr[k] = rrq[id][k]; end
last_beats = rdn[id]; rdn[id] = 0; arq_head[id] = (h + 1) % 8; done = done + 1;
end
end
beat_m = 0;
endtask
// A complete read: AR, then every beat, into rd[] and rr[].
task automatic axi_read(input logic [ID_W-1:0] id, input int unsigned addr, input int len, input logic [2:0] size,
input logic [1:0] burst, input logic lock = 0);
ar_issue(id, addr, len, size, burst, lock);
r_collect(1);
endtask
// The table of a burst before it runs: the address, lanes and strobe of every beat.
task automatic beat_table(input int unsigned addr, input int len, input logic [2:0] size, input logic [1:0] burst);
logic [15:0] lanes;
logic [63:0] s;
int unsigned a;
$display("burst at 0x%0h: %0d beat%0s of %0d byte%0s, %0s, bus %0d bytes", addr, len + 1, len ? "s" : "", 1 << size, size ? "s" : "",
burst_name(burst), BUS_BYTES);
$display(" beat address lanes strobe");
for (int n = 0; n <= len; n++) begin
lanes = beat_lanes(addr, len, size, burst, n, BUS_BYTES);
s = beat_strb(addr, len, size, burst, n, BUS_BYTES);
a = beat_addr(addr, len, size, burst, n);
$display(" %4d 0x%05h %0d-%0d %b", n, a[19:0], lanes[7:0], lanes[15:8], s[BUS_BYTES-1:0]);
end
if (crosses_4k(addr, len, size, burst)) $display(" this burst crosses a 4 KB boundary");
endtask
// One byte of the memory that owns an address (the fabric's second memory above 0x8000).
function automatic logic [7:0] mem_byte(input int unsigned a);
`ifdef AXI_MEM1
if (a >= 32'h8000) return `AXI_MEM1.mem[a];
`endif
return `AXI_MEM.mem[a];
endfunction
task automatic set_byte(input int unsigned a, input logic [7:0] v);
`ifdef AXI_MEM1
if (a >= 32'h8000) `AXI_MEM1.mem[a] = v;
else `AXI_MEM.mem[a] = v;
`else
`AXI_MEM.mem[a] = v;
`endif
endtask
// The memory, n bytes from addr, one bus word per group.
task automatic dump(input int unsigned addr, input int n);
string line;
int unsigned a = (addr / 16) * 16;
while (a < addr + n) begin
line = $sformatf("0x%05h ", a[19:0]);
for (int i = 0; i < 16; i++) begin
if (i % BUS_BYTES == 0) line = {line, " "};
line = {line, $sformatf(" %02h", mem_byte(a + i))};
end
$display("%s", line);
a = a + 16;
end
endtask
// Fill n bytes from addr with first, first+1, ... so untouched bytes stay recognisable.
task automatic mem_fill(input int unsigned addr, input int n, input logic [7:0] first = 8'h00);
for (int i = 0; i < n; i++) set_byte(addr + i, first + i[7:0]);
endtask
// Drive nothing for n cycles.
task automatic idle(input int n);
repeat (n) @(posedge aclk);
#1;
endtask
Check yourself
Remember
- An ID names a stream. Requests on one ID are answered in request order; requests on different IDs may be answered in any order.
- The rule exists because a response carries only the ID: with two transactions open on one ID, a manager can pair answers with requests by order and nothing else.
- A subordinate holds the faster response; an interconnect holds the later request until the earlier responses of that ID are back.
- Reusing an ID costs head-of-line blocking: in the bench a fast read waited four extra edges behind a slow one with the same ID.
- A protocol checker catches same-ID reordering only when the lengths differ; otherwise only a data check keyed by ID sees it.
Practice
- The same-ID order checker Verify · Hard