G2.3.2 Make the Bench Check Itself

EasyVerify15 minIcarus · browser samples / server checks11 hidden designsReview the topic

Turn a testbench that only prints into one that checks every row of a majority voter and counts the wrong ones.

Hardware context: A room thermostat that places a heater control block, and the testbench of a three-input voter. Write a self-checking bench that catches eleven faulty voters, seven of them wrong on one row only, and passes the correct one.

A team tests its majority voter with a bench that prints eight rows. Someone looks at the rows and says they are fine. Last week a voter with one pair of inputs missing passed that way.

This is a Verify problem. You write the bench, not the voter. Your bench drives the inputs a, b and c and reads y. It adds 1 to errors for every row where y is wrong.

The check runs your bench on one correct voter and on eleven faulty ones. Some faulty voters are wrong on one row only. You pass when errors stays 0 on the correct voter and ends above 0 on every faulty voter.

Signals in the Timeline

SignalWidthRole
variant4input of each check
Full specification
The bench you write (keep these ports)
module bench (
  output logic a,          // you drive the three inputs of the voter
  output logic b,
  output logic c,
  input  logic y,          // the output of the voter
  output int   errors      // add 1 for every row where y is wrong
);
  // your initial block
endmodule
RuleDetail
The votery must be 1 when at least two of a, b and c are 1, and 0 otherwise.
TimingThe voter is plain gates. Wait 1 ns after you change the inputs before you read y. The check runs with a timescale of 1 ns, so #1 is 1 ns.
Time limitYour bench must finish within 35 ns.
errorsStart at 0. Add 1 for each wrong row. Never count down.
Expected valueCompute it in the bench. Do not copy the expression of the voter: count the 1s, or list the rows.

For each voter you get alarm = yes or no. The correct voter must give no alarm. Each faulty voter must give an alarm.

Examples

Example 1

The Correct Voter Must Not Raise an Alarm
Input
Voter: the correct design
Output
alarm = no

On the correct voter every row matches, so errors must still be 0 at the end.

Example 2

A Voter That Needs All Three Votes
Input
Voter: All three votes needed (y is 1 only for the row 111)
Output
alarm = yes

This voter gives 0 for the rows with exactly two 1s. A bench that checks those rows counts three errors.

Example 3

A Voter with One Pair Missing
Input
Voter: One pair missing (y is 0 for the row 011)
Output
alarm = yes

This voter is wrong in one row only, 011. Only a bench that visits that row can catch it.

Constraints and Contract

  • Use only your ports: no names from inside the voter or the fixture.
  • Drive a, b and c from one initial block, and finish within the time limit.

Hints

Hint 1

A loop from 0 to 7 visits every row. The three low bits of the loop counter are the three inputs.

Hint 2

The expected output is 1 when the inputs hold two or three 1s. The sum a + b + c counts them.

Hint 3

Compare with !== so that an unknown output also counts as wrong. Then add 1 to errors.

What the grader checks: Your bench runs on one correct majority voter and on eleven voters with one planted fault each. Seven of them are wrong on a single row, one fault for each row. Passing shows that your bench checks every row and raises no false alarm.

12 checks on Icarus · browser samples / server checks. Run the examples first, then check the full regression. Full checks use the server judge. Downloads contain public samples only. A passing result establishes the tested cases, not a proof for all possible inputs.

See all 2 steps and the final capstone

Report a problem with this page

Your code SystemVerilogSaved locally
Ln 1, Col 1Tab indents · Ctrl/⌘ + Enter runs samples
Not run yet

The Correct Voter Must Not Raise an Alarm

Input
Voter: the correct design
Expected output
alarm = no

On the correct voter every row matches, so errors must still be 0 at the end.

Run samples executes all 3 public checks. Check all tests runs 12 checks on the server.

Icarus · browser samples / server checks