The Channel: Loss, Reflections and Crosstalk

Measure a channel the way its datasheet does: insertion loss, return loss and crosstalk, and the loss budget a link must fit.

You Will Be Able To

  • Read insertion loss from a frequency response and relate it to length.
  • Predict the reflection from an impedance step and convert it to return loss.
  • Explain near-end and far-end crosstalk.
  • Check a channel against a loss budget at the Nyquist frequency.
Lesson
P10.8
Time
30 min
Runs on
ngspice
Check
5 questions

The same 10 Gb/s link works on a short board and fails on one twice as long. Doubling the bench channel took its loss at 5 GHz from 3.7 to 13.0 dB.

Four S-Parameters Describe a Channel at Each FrequencyA wave goes in at one port. Part comes out at the other port; part comes back.
  • I/O
  • Channel / handshake
  • Measure
  • Data
Four S-parameters describe a channel at each frequencyA wave goes in at one port. Part comes out at the other port; part comes back. io Port 1 transmitter side channel Channel trace, connector,cable io Port 2 receiver side measure S11 return loss measure S21 insertion loss incidentreflectedtransmitted
  1. io Port 1transmitter side
    • incident → Channel
  2. channel Channeltrace, connector, cable
    • Port 2
    • reflected → S11
  3. io Port 2receiver side
    • transmitted → S21
  4. measure S21insertion loss
  5. measure S11return loss
  1. Send a wave

    A sine wave of one frequency goes in at port 1.

  2. S21: what gets through

    The ratio of the wave out of port 2 to the wave in. In dB it is negative; its size is the insertion loss.

  3. S11: what comes back

    The ratio of the wave reflected at port 1 to the wave in. Its size in dB is the return loss: larger is better.

  4. Differential names

    For a differential pair the names gain two letters: SDD21 for the differential insertion loss, SDD11 or SDD22 for return loss.

Read the diagram as text
  • Port 1: transmitter side
  • Channel: trace, connector, cable
  • Port 2: receiver side
  • S11: return loss
  • S21: insertion loss
  • Port 1 → Channel: incident
  • Channel → Port 2
  • Channel → S11: reflected
  • Port 2 → S21: transmitted

USB4 writes its transmitter return-loss mask as SDD22 (§3.1.3.1.1.2). S12 and S22 are the same ratios seen from the other end.

Insertion Loss

Insertion loss is how much of a signal a channel loses between its two ends, at each frequency. Traces lose more at high frequencies, so the loss curve falls with frequency.

AC analysisInsertion Loss Grows with Length and with FrequencyThe bench channel at four lengths. k scales the resistance and capacitance of every section.
  • k = 0.3
  • k = 0.6
  • k = 1
  • k = 1.5
-40 dB-35 dB-30 dB-25 dB-20 dB-15 dB-10 dB-5 dB0k = 0.3, k = 0.6, k = 1, k = 1.510 MHz100 MHz1 GHz10 GHz100 GHzFrequencyNyquist of 10 Gb/s-40 dB-30 dB-20 dB-10 dB0k = 0.3, k = 0.6, k = 1, k = 1.510 MHz1 GHz100 GHzFrequencyNyquist of 10 Gb/s
Read the plot as a table
Frequencyk = 0.3k = 0.6k = 1k = 1.5
10 MHz-0.000004951 dB-0.00002294 dB-0.00007663 dB-0.0002132 dB
100 MHz-0.0004951 dB-0.002294 dB-0.007657 dB-0.02127 dB
1 GHz-0.04925 dB-0.2238 dB-0.7092 dB-1.764 dB
10 GHz-3.32 dB-8.282 dB-14.53 dB-22.8 dB

ngspice AC runs. Loss at 5 GHz for k = 0.3, 0.6, 1, 1.5: 1.1, 3.7, 7.8, 13.0 dB.

The number that matters is the loss at the Nyquist frequency, half the bit rate: 5 GHz for 10 Gb/s. A bit pattern of 1010 is a 5 GHz square wave, the fastest thing the link sends.

On the bench the loss grows faster than the length. At 5 GHz, k = 0.6, 1 and 1.5 lose 3.7, 7.8 and 13.0 dB.

Reflections and Return Loss

A line has a characteristic impedance Z0. A wave travels along it unchanged until the impedance changes. There, part of it reflects.

The reflected fraction is Γ = (ZL − Z0) / (ZL + Z0). A matched end reflects nothing; an open end reflects everything; a short reflects everything with its sign flipped.

TransientA Step Sent into a Line, Seen at the Sending EndA 1 V step through 50 Ω into a 50 Ω line 200 ps long. Half the step enters the line; the reflection returns 400 ps later.
  • end matched
  • end twice Z0
  • end half Z0
  • end open
00.2 V0.4 V0.6 V0.8 V1.0 V1.2 Vend matched, end twice Z0, end half Z0, end open00.2 ns0.4 ns0.6 ns0.8 ns1.0 nsTime00.2 V0.4 V0.6 V0.8 V1.0 V1.2 Vend matched, end twice Z0, end half Z0, end open00.5 ns1.0 nsTime
Read the plot as a table
Timeend matchedend twice Z0end half Z0end open
0 s0 V0 V0 V0 V
200 ps500 mV500 mV500 mV500 mV
400 ps500 mV500 mV500 mV500 mV
600 ps500 mV666.7 mV333.3 mV1 V
800 ps500 mV666.7 mV333.3 mV1 V
1 ns500 mV666.7 mV333.3 mV1 V

ngspice transient of a lossless line. The level after the reflection tells the load: 0.5 V matched, higher for a larger load, lower for a smaller one.

The bench read the sending end 800 ps after the step. Matched, twice Z0, half Z0 and open gave 0.500, 0.667, 0.333, 1.000 V: 0.5 × (1 + Γ).

Return loss is the reflection in dB, −20 log10 |Γ|. A load of twice Z0 reflects a third: 9.5 dB of return loss. Larger is better.

USB 3.2 limits the integrated return loss of a linear re-driver to −17 dB, against an 85 Ω reference (§E.6.4.5). USB4 gives its transmitter a return-loss mask, SDD22, from −8.5 dB at low frequency (§3.1.3.1.1.2).

A reflection does not vanish. It travels back and reflects again at the source if that is not matched. It reaches the receiver late, as a ghost of an earlier bit.

Crosstalk

Two traces side by side are coupled by the capacitance between them. An edge on one, the aggressor, puts a small pulse on the other, the victim.

TransientA Step on One Line, a Pulse on Its NeighbourTwo bench channels side by side, 0.05 pF of coupling per section. The aggressor gets a 1 V step.
  • aggressor drive (left axis)
  • victim near end (right axis)
  • victim far end (right axis)
00.2 V0.4 V0.6 V0.8 V1.0 V1.2 Vaggressor drive05 mV10 mV15 mV20 mVvictim near end, victim far end00.2 ns0.4 ns0.6 ns0.8 ns1.0 nsTime00.2 V0.4 V0.6 V0.8 V1.0 V1.2 Vaggressor drive05 mV10 mV15 mV20 mVvictim near end, victim far end00.5 ns1.0 nsTime
Read the plot as a table
Timeaggressor drivevictim near endvictim far end
0 s0 V0 V0 V
200 ps1 V12.88 mV14.62 mV
400 ps1 V2.254 mV2.559 mV
600 ps1 V262.3 µV297.7 µV
800 ps1 V27.09 µV30.76 µV
1 ns1 V2.666 µV3.027 µV

ngspice transient. The victim's near end peaks at 16.1 mV and its far end at 17.8 mV.

Near-end crosstalk (NEXT) appears at the victim end next to the aggressor's driver. Far-end crosstalk (FEXT) appears at the end next to the aggressor's receiver.

On the bench a 1 V step gave 16.1 mV of NEXT and 17.8 mV of FEXT: -35.8 and -35.0 dB.

USB 3.2 limits the integrated NEXT and FEXT of a re-driver to −35 dB between any two pairs (§E.6.4.6). It notes that the re-driver's gain amplifies the crosstalk it lets through.

Crosstalk is noise that tracks a neighbour's data. An equalizer that boosts high frequencies boosts it too.

The Loss Budget

A link is designed to a loss budget: the largest insertion loss at Nyquist that its equalizers can make up.

BudgetLoss at NyquistSource
USB 3.2 host or device (informative)8.5 dB§E.6.4.8
USB 3.2 end to end (informative)23 dB§E.6.4.8
USB4 Gen 2 receiver test, maximum-loss case18 dB at 5 GHz§3.1.4.2
AMD transceiver wizard: DFE mode above14 dBPG182
Bench channel at k = 1.513.0 dB at 5 GHzngspice run above

The bench rows are bench values. USB 3.2 calls its budgets informative.

USB 3.2 shows a channel that loses about 33 dB, well past its 23 dB budget (§E.6.4.8). Even the highest re-driver gain cannot rescue it.

P10.9's passive CTLE lifted 5 GHz by about 9.9 dB against DC. That covers the long bench channel's 7.8 dB, but not the 13.0 dB of k = 1.5.

USB 3.2 adds that insertion loss is not the only limit: crosstalk and reflections also eat the margin (§E.6.4.8).

Try It

Four copies of one line, each with a different end. Each meas line reads the sending end after the reflection has come back.

The matched line reads 0.5 V: the source and the line form a 2 : 1 divider, and nothing returns.

Change one end to 5 Ω and predict the level before you run: Γ = −45 / 55, so about 0.09 V.

SPICEngspice 42 · simulator service
Edit the netlist, then run it
Expected measurements: back0 ≈ 0.5 back1 ≈ 0.6666667 back2 ≈ 0.3333333 back3 ≈ 1

Check Yourself

Predict the outputThe same line ends in 12.5 Ω. What does the meas line print? (Format: back = 1.000000e-01.)
* A 1 V step through 50 ohm into a 50 ohm, 200 ps line, ended in 12.5 ohm
V1 s 0 PULSE(0 1 50p 20p 20p 10n 20n)
Rs s in 50
T1 in 0 out 0 Z0=50 TD=200p
Rl out 0 12.5
.control
tran 2p 1n
meas tran back find v(in) at=800p
.endc
.end
ConceptWhy is a channel's loss quoted at half the bit rate?
ConceptA line of 50 Ω ends in an open circuit. What fraction of the wave reflects?
ConceptWhere does near-end crosstalk appear?
ConceptA channel loses 30 dB at Nyquist against a 23 dB budget. What does that mean?

Common Mistakes

Wrong Quote a channel's loss without a frequency.

Loss grows with frequency; the long bench channel loses 7.8 dB at 5 GHz and almost nothing at 10 MHz.

Fix Quote insertion loss at the Nyquist frequency of the bit rate, and compare it with the budget there.

Wrong Call a return loss of 3 dB good because the number is small.

Return loss is the reflection's size below the incident wave; a small number means a large reflection.

Fix Look for large return loss, such as the 17 dB USB 3.2 asks of a re-driver.

Wrong Terminate an 85 Ω differential pair with 50 Ω per pair.

Any step in impedance reflects; 50 Ω against 85 Ω reflects about a quarter of the wave.

Fix Match the termination to the line's impedance, differential to differential.

Wrong Treat crosstalk as random noise.

It follows the aggressor's data and edges, so it is bounded, deterministic and correlated with a neighbour.

Fix Budget it as deterministic jitter and noise, and remember that equalizer gain amplifies it.

Remember

  • Insertion loss (S21) is what a channel loses end to end; quote it at the Nyquist frequency.
  • An impedance step reflects Γ = (ZL − Z0) / (ZL + Z0); return loss is that reflection in dB.
  • Crosstalk couples a neighbour's edges onto a victim, at the near end and the far end.
  • A link is designed to a loss budget at Nyquist that its equalizers can make up.

Practice

Report a problem with this page