Leakage: Threshold, Temperature and Multi-Vt

Explain why a lower threshold makes a transistor faster and leakier, and decide where a design should spend it.

You Will Be Able To

  • Compare the off current and the on current of each threshold flavour.
  • Predict how temperature and input state change the leakage of a gate.
  • Choose which cells of a design get the fast, leaky flavour.
Lesson
W1.3
Time
30 min
Runs on
ngspice
Check
5 questions

A team wanted more speed, so it swapped every cell of a block to the low-threshold library. Timing passed. The standby current of the block rose more than ten times, and the battery target was lost.

DC sweepThree PMOS Flavours from off to on, at 25 °CW = 1 µm. The standard and HVT devices have L = 0.15 µm; the LVT device needs L = 0.35 µm. Each grid line up is ten times more current.
  • standard
  • HVT
  • LVT
100 fA10 pA1 nA100 nA10 µA1 mADrain current00.2 V0.4 V0.6 V0.8 V1.0 V1.2 V1.4 V1.6 V1.8 VSource-to-gate voltage100 fA10 pA1 nA100 nA10 µA1 mADrain current00.5 V1.0 V1.5 VSource-to-gate voltage
Read the plot as a table
Source-to-gate voltagestandardHVTLVT
0 V280.2 pA1.514 pA3.007 nA
200 mV6.282 nA2.218 pA222.9 nA
400 mV109.7 nA540.2 pA2.659 µA
600 mV1.951 µA46.65 nA10.09 µA
800 mV11.71 µA1.026 µA23.28 µA
1 V31.94 µA9.399 µA42.78 µA
1.2 V61.58 µA30.77 µA68.35 µA
1.4 V98.52 µA61.61 µA98.5 µA
1.6 V140 µA97.28 µA130.6 µA
1.8 V183 µA133.7 µA161.9 µA

Measured on ngspice 42 with the SKY130 tt models. The curves end close together and start far apart.

The plot shows why: the flavours differ a little when on and enormously when off.

A Lower Threshold Buys Speed and Costs Leakage

The threshold voltage Vt is the gate voltage where a transistor starts to conduct well. A foundry offers the same transistor with several thresholds. These are the flavours: standard, high-threshold (HVT) and low-threshold (LVT).

Read the plot from the left. With no gate drive the device is off, and the current there is the off current Ioff. Below the threshold the current grows several times for every 0.1 V of gate drive. Here that is about 4 times for the standard PMOS and 13 times for the NMOS. So a threshold that is 0.25 V higher can mean hundreds of times less current when off.

Read it from the right. Fully on, the current is the on current Ion. It sets how fast the device charges a load. Here the threshold matters much less.

Device (W = 1 µm)VtIoffIonIoff at 100 °C
PMOS standard0.520 V280 pA183 µA11.5 nA
PMOS HVT0.769 V1.51 pA134 µA7.17 pA
PMOS LVT (L = 0.35 µm)0.215 V3.01 nA162 µA98.9 nA
NMOS standard0.600 V216 fA477 µA—
NMOS LVT0.502 V2.90 pA545 µA—

tt corner, 1.8 V. Vt is read where the current reaches 100 nA × W/L. That is our definition; other definitions give other numbers.

Compare the standard PMOS with the HVT PMOS. The HVT device leaks 185 times less. It also delivers 27 % less on current, so a gate built from it is slower.

Now compare the two NMOS devices. The LVT device gives 14 % more on current and leaks 13.5 times more.

Heat Multiplies Leakage

DC sweepThe Same Sweep at 100 °COnly .temp changed. Compare the left ends of the curves with the 25 °C plot.
  • standard
  • HVT
  • LVT
1 pA100 pA10 nA1 µA100 µADrain current00.2 V0.4 V0.6 V0.8 V1.0 V1.2 V1.4 V1.6 V1.8 VSource-to-gate voltage1 pA100 pA10 nA1 µA100 µADrain current00.5 V1.0 V1.5 VSource-to-gate voltage
Read the plot as a table
Source-to-gate voltagestandardHVTLVT
0 V11.52 nA7.167 pA98.91 nA
200 mV129.8 nA596.6 pA1.354 µA
400 mV1.414 µA35.78 nA5.959 µA
600 mV7.954 µA656.2 nA14.82 µA
800 mV22.82 µA5.446 µA28.49 µA
1 V46.17 µA20.19 µA47.39 µA
1.2 V77.13 µA44.69 µA71.32 µA
1.4 V114 µA75.95 µA99.17 µA
1.6 V154.6 µA110.6 µA129 µA
1.8 V196.2 µA145.7 µA158.6 µA

Measured on ngspice 42. The on currents barely move. The off currents of the standard and LVT devices rise by more than a decade.

A warm chip leaks more for two reasons. The threshold falls as the temperature rises. The slope below the threshold also gets flatter, so more current remains at zero gate drive. Lesson E2.6 measures both effects.

From 25 °C to 100 °C the standard PMOS goes from 280 pA to 11.5 nA: 41.1 times more.

The HVT reading at 0 V rises only 4.74 times, but that does not make HVT less sensitive to heat. At 25 °C it reads the floor; at 100 °C the subthreshold current has risen above it. Compare at 0.3 V, where both devices are below their thresholds. There the HVT current rises 162 times, and the standard one 17 times.

So budget HVT leakage at the hot corner as well. At 100 °C the HVT device still leaks 1,610 times less than the standard one.

A phone in a pocket or a chip inside a closed box is hot. So leakage is budgeted at the hot corner, never at room temperature.

The Input State Changes the Leakage of a Gate

A gate has several transistors, and its inputs decide which of them are off. So one gate has several leakage currents. The run below holds four NAND2 gates in the four input states.

DC sweepSupply Current of One NAND2 in Each Input StateThe supply is swept from 0.6 V to 1.8 V. The label is the input pair A B. All transistors have W = 1 µm.
  • A B = 0 0
  • A B = 0 1
  • A B = 1 0
  • A B = 1 1
10 fA100 fA1 pA10 pA100 pA1 nASupply current0.6 V0.8 V1.0 V1.2 V1.4 V1.6 V1.8 VSupply voltage10 fA100 fA1 pA10 pA100 pA1 nASupply current1.0 V1.5 VSupply voltage
  1. Supply voltage 1.8 VA B = 0 0 = 41.31 fA · A B = 0 1 = 215.6 fA · A B = 1 0 = 186.5 fA · A B = 1 1 = 560.5 pA

    At 1.8 V the four states read 41.3 fA, 216 fA, 186 fA and 560 pA.

Read the plot as a table
Supply voltageA B = 0 0A B = 0 1A B = 1 0A B = 1 1
600 mV30.86 fA63.24 fA71.73 fA22.99 pA
800 mV33.4 fA80.98 fA84.97 fA41.99 pA
1 V35.55 fA101.4 fA100.2 fA74.73 pA
1.2 V37.34 fA124.7 fA117.8 fA129.3 pA
1.4 V38.86 fA151.3 fA137.8 fA217.1 pA
1.6 V40.11 fA181.4 fA160.6 fA353.8 pA
1.8 V41.31 fA215.6 fA186.5 fA560.5 pA

Measured on ngspice 42. The leakiest state passes 13,600 times the current of the quietest.

A BOutputWhich transistors are offSupply current at 1.8 V
0 01Both NMOS, in series41.3 fA
0 11The upper NMOS216 fA
1 01The lower NMOS186 fA
1 10Both PMOS, side by side560 pA

The NAND2 has two PMOS in parallel and two NMOS in series.

With both inputs high, the two PMOS are off. They sit side by side and both leak, and this PMOS is the leaky device. That state passes 560 pA.

With both inputs low, the two NMOS are off in series. This is the stack effect. The node between them rises to 56.6 mV. That small voltage gives the upper NMOS a negative gate-to-source voltage, and the body effect raises its threshold. The same voltage also lowers the drain voltage of the lower one. The pair leaks 5.22 times less than one NMOS alone.

A designer can use this. A block that sleeps can park its inputs in the state that leaks least.

Multi-Vt: Fast Cells Only Where Timing Needs Them

Two Paths Between the Same RegistersArrows show data moving from the launch register to the capture register. The long path decides the clock period. The short path has time to spare.
  • Storage
  • Datapath
  • Data
Two paths between the same registersArrows show data moving from the launch register to the capture register. The long path decides the clock period. The short path has time to spare. storage Launch register Starts both paths datapath Long path No slack: fast cells datapath Short path Slack to spare: HVT storage Capture register Samples both many gatesjust in timefew gatesearly
  1. storage Launch registerStarts both paths
    • many gates → Long path
    • few gates → Short path
  2. datapath Long pathNo slack: fast cells
    • just in time → Capture register
  3. storage Capture registerSamples both
  4. datapath Short pathSlack to spare: HVT
    • early → Capture register
  1. The long path sets the speed

    These gates have no time to spare. They keep the standard or low-threshold flavour, and they pay its leakage.

  2. The short path can be slow

    This data arrives early. Swap its cells to HVT: each PMOS leaks 185 times less, and the path still meets timing.

Read the diagram as text
  • Launch register: Starts both paths
  • Long path: No slack: fast cells
  • Short path: Slack to spare: HVT
  • Capture register: Samples both
  • Launch register → Long path: many gates
  • Long path → Capture register: just in time
  • Launch register → Short path: few gates
  • Short path → Capture register: early

Most paths of a real block are short. So most cells can take the low-leakage flavour.

This method is called multi-Vt design. Some flows start with the low-leakage flavour everywhere and swap cells to a faster flavour on the paths that fail timing. Others start fast and swap the cells on paths with slack to HVT. Both end with fast cells only where timing needs them.

The simulator can hide all of this. The plot below repeats the standard NMOS with the default gmin.

DC sweepTwo NMOS Flavours, and the Standard Device with the Default GminW = 1 µm, L = 0.15 µm, 1.8 V on the drain. The third curve is the standard device again, with gmin left at its default.
  • standard
  • LVT
  • standard, default gmin
100 fA10 pA1 nA100 nA10 µA1 mADrain current00.2 V0.4 V0.6 V0.8 V1.0 V1.2 V1.4 V1.6 V1.8 VGate voltage100 fA10 pA1 nA100 nA10 µA1 mADrain current00.5 V1.0 V1.5 VGate voltage
  1. Gate voltage 0 Vstandard = 215.5 fA · LVT = 2.904 pA · standard, default gmin = 2.016 pA

    Off: the standard device carries 216 fA and the LVT device 2.90 pA. With the default gmin the standard device reads 2.02 pA.

  2. Gate voltage 1.8 Vstandard = 476.9 µA · LVT = 544.6 µA · standard, default gmin = 476.9 µA

    On: 477 µA and 545 µA. The gmin curve has joined the real one long before.

Read the plot as a table
Gate voltagestandardLVTstandard, default gmin
0 V215.5 fA2.904 pA2.016 pA
200 mV34.37 pA458.3 pA36.17 pA
400 mV5.591 nA64.58 nA5.593 nA
600 mV673.8 nA4.704 µA673.8 nA
800 mV18.62 µA54.16 µA18.62 µA
1 V85.23 µA142.7 µA85.23 µA
1.2 V176.4 µA241 µA176.4 µA
1.4 V274.7 µA342.4 µA274.7 µA
1.6 V375.5 µA444.1 µA375.5 µA
1.8 V476.9 µA544.6 µA476.9 µA

Measured on ngspice 42. The default gmin adds about 1.8 pA, nine times this device's own leakage.

Asked in interviews
  1. What is multi-Vt design?

    The library offers each cell with several thresholds. A low threshold is fast and leaky. A high threshold is slow and leaks little. The flow keeps the fast flavour only on paths that would fail timing, and uses the low-leakage flavour everywhere else.

  2. Why does leakage depend on the inputs of a gate?

    The inputs decide which transistors are off and how they are connected. Two off transistors in series leak less than one: the stack effect. Measured here, one NAND2 leaks from 41.3 fA to 560 pA across its four states.

  3. At which corner do you sign off leakage?

    At the fast process corner, the highest supply and the hottest temperature. Leakage rises steeply with temperature: 41.1 times from 25 °C to 100 °C for the standard PMOS here.

Try It

Run the netlist. Vsg sweeps the gate drive of all three devices together. Each device has a 0 V source in its drain, and SPICE reports the current through that source.

Divide ioff_std by ioff_hvt, then ion_std by ion_hvt. The first ratio is the leakage you save. The second is the speed you pay.

Change .temp 25 to .temp 100 and run again. Predict first which ioff moves least. Then delete the .options gmin=1e-18 line and see which reading it spoils.

SPICEngspice 42 · simulator service
Edit the netlist, then run it
Expected measurements: ioff_std = 2.802369e-10 ion_std = 1.829590e-04 at= 1.800000e+00 ioff_hvt = 1.513651e-12 ion_hvt = 1.337345e-04 at= 1.800000e+00 ioff_lvt = 3.006908e-09 ion_lvt = 1.618616e-04 at= 1.800000e+00 vt_std = 5.200544e-01 vt_hvt = 7.694921e-01 vt_lvt = 2.153764e-01

Check Yourself

Predict the outputA block has 1,000,000 PMOS devices, and half of them are off at any time. Each off device leaks 280 pA at 1.8 V. This deck prints the leakage power of the block. Type the line (format: p_leak = 6.48000e-14).
* leakage power of a block: half of its 1,000,000 PMOS devices are off at any time
.param n=1e6 ioff=280p vdd=1.8
Vdd vdd 0 {vdd}
R1 vdd 0 1k
.tran 10p 1n
.meas tran p_leak param='0.5*n*ioff*vdd'
.end
ConceptA block meets timing with 5 % of its paths at zero slack. The other 95 % have slack to spare. Which cells should get the high-threshold flavour?
ConceptFour decks report the off current of the standard NMOS at 25 °C. Which one reports the simulator and not the device?
ConceptThe standard PMOS leaks 280 pA at 25 °C. What did the run measure at 100 °C?
ConceptA block sleeps for hours with its clock stopped. Its NAND2 gates can rest with any inputs. Which resting state saves the most leakage in this library?

Common Mistakes

Wrong Use the low-threshold flavour for every cell.

The LVT NMOS leaks 13.5 times more for 14 % more on current.

Fix Spend the fast flavour only on paths that fail timing without it.

Wrong Quote leakage measured at 25 °C.

The standard PMOS leaks 41.1 times more at 100 °C.

Fix Measure leakage at the hottest corner the product must work in, with the fast process and the highest supply.

Wrong Give one leakage number for a gate.

The NAND2 here leaks 41.3 fA in one input state and 560 pA in another.

Fix Ask which state the gate rests in, and choose that state when you can.

Wrong Carry these 130 nm numbers to a modern process.

Newer processes use lower thresholds and thinner gate oxides, which add gate leakage, and a chip holds far more transistors.

Fix Keep the ratios and the mechanisms, and read the absolute values from the library you use.

Remember

  • A higher threshold cuts the off current hugely and the on current a little: 185 times against 27 % here.
  • Leakage rises steeply with temperature: 41.1 times from 25 °C to 100 °C for the standard PMOS.
  • One gate has several leakage currents. Off transistors in series leak least: the stack effect.
  • Multi-Vt design keeps fast, leaky cells on the critical paths and low-leakage cells everywhere else.
  • SKY130 leaks little. Take the ratios with you, not the picoamps.

Practice

Report a problem with this page