Four Ways to Close a Loop
Name a feedback loop from what it senses and what it returns, then predict which way each port resistance moves.
You Will Be Able To
- Name the four feedback topologies from the sensed and the returned quantity.
- Predict whether feedback raises or lowers the input and the output resistance, and by how much.
- Choose the topology that suits a given source and load.
- Find the topology of a loop in a schematic with two quick tests.
- Lesson
- E10.1
- Time
- 30 min
- Runs on
- ngspice
- Check
- 5 questions
A sensor with 1 MΩ of source resistance needed a gain of 10, and two stages had that gain on paper. With a 10 mV signal one delivered 89.2 mV and the other −0.99 mV.
- stage A output
- stage B output
- Sensor voltage 10 mVstage A output = 89.2 mV · stage B output = -988 µV
At 10 mV stage A gives 89.2 mV. Stage B gives −0.99 mV: the signal is almost gone.
- Sensor voltage 50 mVstage A output = 446 mV · stage B output = -4.94 mV
Both lines are straight. Stage B is not broken. Its input simply loads the sensor.
Read the plot as a table
| Sensor voltage | stage A output | stage B output |
|---|---|---|
| -40 mV | -356.8 mV | 3.952 mV |
| -20 mV | -178.4 mV | 1.976 mV |
| 0 V | 0 V | 0 V |
| 10 mV | 89.2 mV | -988 µV |
| 20 mV | 178.4 mV | -1.976 mV |
| 40 mV | 356.8 mV | -3.952 mV |
| 50 mV | 446 mV | -4.94 mV |
The sensor sees 9.19 MΩ at the input of stage A and 10.1 kΩ at the input of stage B.
The amplifier inside has 100 kΩ between its inputs. Feedback turned that into 9.19 MΩ in one stage and 10.1 kΩ in the other.
Two Choices at Each Port
- Neutral
- Structure
- Series-shunt: a voltage amplifier
It holds the output voltage still. The lab measures Rin = 10 MΩ and Rout = 10 Ω.
- Shunt-shunt: current in, voltage out
It also holds the output voltage, but takes a current. Rin = 1 kΩ and Rout = 10 Ω.
- Series-series: voltage in, current out
It holds the output current still. Rin = 10 MΩ and Rout = 100 kΩ.
- Shunt-series: a current amplifier
It takes a current and holds the output current. Rin = 1 kΩ and Rout = 100 kΩ.
Read the diagram as text
- Series-shunt: returns voltage, senses voltage
- Series-series: returns voltage, senses current
- Shunt-shunt: returns current, senses voltage
- Shunt-series: returns current, senses current
- Series-shunt → Series-series: sense current
- Shunt-shunt → Shunt-series: sense current
- Series-shunt → Shunt-shunt: return current
- Series-series → Shunt-series: return current
The bare amplifier has Rin = 100 kΩ and Rout = 1 kΩ. Every loop here has a loop gain of 99.
A feedback loop senses a quantity at the output and returns a part of it to the input. The sensed quantity is the output voltage or the output current. The returned quantity is a voltage or a current.
To sense a voltage, the network connects across the output: a shunt connection. To sense a current, the network sits in the path of the load current: a series connection.
To return a voltage, the network sits in series with the input source, so the two voltages subtract. To return a current, it connects to the input node, so the two currents subtract.
What Each Choice Does to a Port
- Sense
E_F reads the output voltage. It connects across the output, so this is a shunt connection.
- Return
E_F drives the other input. The amplifier sees vin − 0.099·vout: the voltages subtract in series.
Read the circuit as text
- v_in voltage source: + →
n1, − →0 - A = 1000 op-amp: −in →
n2, +in →n1, out →n3 - E_F voltage source (0.099·v_out): + →
n2, − →0 - out port: terminal →
n3
An ideal controlled source stands for the feedback network, so the network adds no load.
Take the series input first. The loop makes the returned voltage follow vin. Only a small difference is left across the 100 kΩ. Little current flows, so the source sees a high resistance.
At a shunt input the loop removes most of the input current. The input node barely moves, so the source sees a low resistance.
At the output, a loop that senses voltage fights any change of that voltage. The output looks like a voltage source: low resistance. A loop that senses current fights any change of the current. The output looks like a current source: high resistance.
| Topology | Rin | Rout | Closed-loop gain |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bare amplifier | 100 kΩ | 1 kΩ | 1000 V/V |
| Series-shunt | 10.00 MΩ | 10.00 Ω | 10.00 V/V |
| Shunt-shunt | 1.000 kΩ | 10.00 Ω | 1.000 MΩ (V/A) |
| Series-series | 10.00 MΩ | 100.0 kΩ | 10.00 mA/V |
| Shunt-series | 1.000 kΩ | 100.0 kΩ | 1000 A/A |
Each resistance is the bare value times or divided by 1 + T = 100.
The loop gain T is the gain once around the loop. Here T = 99 in all four. Series raises a port resistance by 1 + T. Shunt lowers it by 1 + T.
The lab shows this with a 1 kΩ load. The series-shunt loop keeps its voltage gain at 9.90 of 10. The series-series loop keeps its current at 9.90 mA/V of 10 mA/V. Without feedback, a 1 kΩ load on a 1 kΩ output halves the voltage.
Find the Topology in a Schematic
- Sense
The load current flows through the ammeter. F_F copies a part of it. Open the load and the feedback is gone: a series connection.
iout
- Return
F_F takes its current from the input node, where iin arrives. The currents subtract at one node: a shunt connection.
0.00099·iout
Read the circuit as text
- i_in current source: + →
0, − →n1 - F_F current source (0.00099·i_out): + →
n1, − →0 - A = 1000 op-amp: −in →
n1, +in →0, out →n2 - load voltage source (0 V ammeter): + →
n2, − →0
The other two topologies swap one port each: series input with series output, or shunt input with shunt output.
Two tests name any loop. First the output: short the output node to ground. If the feedback signal disappears, the loop senses voltage. If it disappears when you open the load instead, the loop senses current.
Then the input: does the feedback arrive at the same node as the input signal? Then it is shunt, and the signals add as currents. Does it arrive at a different terminal? Then it is series.
One transistor already gave you two of the four. The lab measures an NMOS, W/L = 4/0.5 µm at 20 µA.
| Circuit | Loop | Measured | Against the bare device |
|---|---|---|---|
| Source at AC ground, looking into the drain | none | 349.1 kΩ | — |
| 10 kΩ in the source, looking into the drain | series-series | 1.395 MΩ | 4.00 times higher |
| Source follower, looking into the source | series-shunt | 3.338 kΩ | 105 times lower |
Lessons E3.4 and E3.5 derived these two stages without the word feedback.
The source resistor senses the drain current and returns a voltage at the source, in series with vGS. The follower senses its own output voltage and returns all of it. Their loop gains differ from the lab's 99. The source resistor gives T near 3 and the follower T near 104.
Asked in interviews
Name the four feedback topologies and what each does to Rin and Rout.
Series-shunt raises Rin and lowers Rout. Shunt-shunt lowers both. Series-series raises both. Shunt-series lowers Rin and raises Rout. Each change is a factor of about 1 + T.
How do you tell voltage sensing from current sensing in a schematic?
Short the output node to ground. If the feedback disappears, the loop senses voltage. If it disappears when the load is opened instead, the loop senses current.
A sensor has 1 MΩ of source resistance. Which input connection do you choose?
Series. It raises the input resistance by 1 + T, so the sensor is not loaded. In the hook the series stage shows 9.19 MΩ and the shunt stage 10.1 kΩ.
Try It
Each feedback network is one controlled source. E returns a voltage from a voltage and G a current from a voltage. H returns a voltage from a current and F a current from a current. F and H read the current of a 0 V source, which also stands for a shorted load.
Run 1 drives each input with AC 1 and reads the input resistance and the gain. A voltage source of 1 V gives Rin = 1/|i|. A current source of 1 A gives Rin = |v|.
Run 2 silences the inputs with alter and tests each output. A shunt output takes a 1 A test current. A series output takes a 1 V test source inside the load path.
Predict before each change. Halve the gain of EA to 500: which eight numbers change, and to what? Then make EFA 0.999: what happens to gain_a and rout_a?
Run the netlist to draw its plots here.
rin_a = 1.000000e+07 gain_a = 1.000000e+01 rin_b = 1.000000e+03 gain_b = 1.000000e+06 rin_c = 1.000000e+07 gain_c = 1.000000e-02 rin_d = 1.000000e+03 gain_d = 1.000000e+03 gain_a_load = 9.900990e+00 gain_c_load = 9.900990e-03 rout_a = 1.000000e+01 rout_b = 1.000000e+01 rout_c = 1.000000e+05 rout_d = 1.000000e+05 ro_bare = 3.491105e+05 ro_degen = 1.394843e+06 ro_follower = 3.338424e+03Check Yourself
Common Mistakes
Wrong Say that negative feedback always raises the input resistance and lowers the output resistance.
That is true only for series-shunt; the lab's shunt inputs fall to 1 kΩ and its series outputs rise to 100 kΩ.
Fix Decide each port on its own: series raises the resistance by 1 + T, and shunt lowers it by 1 + T.
Wrong Put an inverting op-amp stage behind a source with a high resistance.
The inverting stage has a shunt input, so the hook's 1 MΩ sensor sees 10.1 kΩ and loses 99 % of its signal.
Fix Use the non-inverting stage, whose series input shows 9.19 MΩ in the hook.
Wrong Name the topology from the amplifier inside the loop.
The same amplifier makes all four in the lab; only the two connections of the network differ.
Fix Look at the network: across the output or in series with the load, and to the input node or to another terminal.
Remember
- A loop senses the output voltage (shunt) or the output current (series), and returns a voltage (series) or a current (shunt).
- A series connection raises that port's resistance by 1 + T. A shunt connection lowers it by 1 + T.
- The loop holds still the quantity it senses: voltage sensing makes a voltage source, current sensing a current source.
- Short the output to see what is sensed. Check which node the feedback reaches to see what is returned.
- A source resistor is a series-series loop and a source follower is a series-shunt loop.