What Feedback Does to Noise and Distortion

Close a loop around one op-amp and measure what improves: distortion falls by 1 + T, input noise does not fall at all.

You Will Be Able To

  • Explain why feedback leaves the input-referred noise of an amplifier unchanged.
  • Predict the noise that a feedback network adds from its two resistors.
  • Predict a closed-loop harmonic from the open-loop harmonic and the loop gain at its frequency.
  • Measure harmonic levels from a transient run, and state the numerical floor of the method.
Lesson
E10.6
Time
35 min
Runs on
ngspice
Check
5 questions

A sensor team closed a loop around its op-amp to clean up the signal. The second harmonic fell by 35 dB, but the noise at the input went from 62.0 to 65.3 nV/√Hz.

DC sweepHarmonics of a 100 kHz Tone, Open Loop and Closed LoopLevel of each harmonic below the 100 kHz tone. The output swing is 0.2 V in both.
  • open loop
  • closed loop, gain −1
-160 dB-140 dB-120 dB-100 dB-80 dB-60 dB-40 dB-20 dB0Level100 kHz150 kHz200 kHz250 kHz300 kHz350 kHz400 kHz450 kHz500 kHzFrequency−59.1 dBc−94.1 dBc−81.1 dBc−112.8 dBc-200 dB-150 dB-100 dB-50 dB0Level100 kHz200 kHz300 kHz400 kHz500 kHzFrequency−59.1 dBc−94.1 dBc−81.1 dBc−112.8 dBc
Read the plot as a table
Frequencyopen loopclosed loop, gain −1
100 kHz0 dB0 dB
150 kHz-29.53 dB-47.06 dB
200 kHz-59.06 dB-94.13 dB
250 kHz-70.07 dB-103.5 dB
300 kHz-81.08 dB-112.8 dB
350 kHz-102.9 dB-129.2 dB
400 kHz-124.6 dB-145.6 dB
450 kHz-124.1 dB-148.8 dB
500 kHz-123.6 dB-152 dB

Only the five harmonic frequencies are measured. Levels below −140 dBc are close to the floor of the method.

Feedback treats the two differently, and this lesson measures why.

Feedback Leaves the Input Noise Where It Was

One Loop, Two Ways InBoth sources rest at 0.9 V. The op-amp is OPA-B of E6.
One loop, two ways in++−+vin​RG​50 kΩvp​OPA-BRF​50 kΩCL​2 pFout
  1. v_in · voltage source+ → n1 · − → 0
  2. R_G · resistor50 kΩpin 1 → n2 · pin 2 → n1
  3. v_p · voltage source+ → n3 · − → 0
  4. OPA-B · op-amp−in → n2 · +in → n3 · out → n4
  5. R_F · resistor50 kΩpin 1 → n4 · pin 2 → n2
  6. C_L · capacitor2 pFpin 1 → n4 · pin 2 → 0
  7. out · portterminal → n4
  8. g1 · groundgnd → 0
  9. g2 · groundgnd → 0
  10. g3 · groundgnd → 0
  1. The loop

    RF and RG return half of the output to the − input. The loop gain is T = A/2.

  2. The noise test

    Drive the + input with vp. The gain is 1 + RF/RG = 2. A second loop, with RG = 5.56 kΩ, has a gain of 10.

  3. The distortion test

    Drive RG with vin. The gain is −RF/RG = −1, and both op-amp inputs stay near 0.9 V.

Read the circuit as text
  • v_in voltage source: + → n1, − → 0
  • R_G resistor (50 kΩ): pin 1 → n2, pin 2 → n1
  • v_p voltage source: + → n3, − → 0
  • OPA-B op-amp: −in → n2, +in → n3, out → n4
  • R_F resistor (50 kΩ): pin 1 → n4, pin 2 → n2
  • C_L capacitor (2 pF): pin 1 → n4, pin 2 → 0
  • out port: terminal → n4

The lab also keeps one op-amp with its loop open, loaded by the same 50 kΩ.

Input-referred noise is the output noise divided by the gain. It is the noise a signal at the input must beat.

AC analysisInput-Referred Noise: Open Loop and Two Closed-Loop GainsNoise density at the + input. The lowest line is the feedback network of the gain-2 loop alone.
  • open loop
  • gain 2
  • gain 10
  • network alone
10 nV/rtHz100 nV/rtHz1 µV/rtHz10 µV/rtHzInput-referred noise100 Hz1 kHz10 kHz100 kHz1 MHz10 MHzFrequency10 nV/rtHz100 nV/rtHz1 µV/rtHz10 µV/rtHzInput-referred noise100 Hz10 kHz1 MHzFrequency
  1. Frequency 1 kHzopen loop = 409.6 nV/rtHz · gain 2 = 410.1 nV/rtHz · gain 10 = 409.7 nV/rtHz · network alone = 20.36 nV/rtHz

    At 1 kHz flicker noise dominates. Open loop and gain 2 both read 410 nV/√Hz.

  2. Frequency 100 kHzopen loop = 62.02 nV/rtHz · gain 2 = 65.27 nV/rtHz · gain 10 = 62.68 nV/rtHz · network alone = 20.36 nV/rtHz

    At 100 kHz the open loop reads 62.0 nV/√Hz, gain 10 reads 62.7 and gain 2 reads 65.3.

  3. Frequency 1 MHzopen loop = 31.47 nV/rtHz · gain 2 = 37.47 nV/rtHz · gain 10 = 32.76 nV/rtHz · network alone = 20.36 nV/rtHz

    At 1 MHz the network matters more: 31.5 nV/√Hz open, 37.5 at gain 2.

Read the plot as a table
Frequencyopen loopgain 2gain 10network alone
100 Hz1.097 µV/rtHz1.097 µV/rtHz1.097 µV/rtHz20.36 nV/rtHz
1 kHz409.6 nV/rtHz410.1 nV/rtHz409.7 nV/rtHz20.36 nV/rtHz
10 kHz155 nV/rtHz156.3 nV/rtHz155.3 nV/rtHz20.36 nV/rtHz
100 kHz62.02 nV/rtHz65.27 nV/rtHz62.68 nV/rtHz20.36 nV/rtHz
1 MHz31.47 nV/rtHz37.47 nV/rtHz32.76 nV/rtHz20.36 nV/rtHz
10 MHz26.34 nV/rtHz33.19 nV/rtHz27.84 nV/rtHz20.36 nV/rtHz

Closing the loop never puts a curve below the open-loop one.

Feedback divides the gain by 1 + T. It divides the output noise by the same factor. Their ratio, the input-referred noise, stays where it was.

A loop cannot tell noise from signal. Both arrive at the same input.

The Network Adds Its Own Noise

Each resistor of the network makes thermal noise. Seen from the input, RF and RG act as one resistor RF ∥ RG in series with the − input.

LoopRF ∥ RGNetwork aloneInput noise at 100 kHzAbove open loop
Open loopnonenone62.02 nV/√Hz0
Gain 105 kΩ9.1 nV/√Hz62.68 nV/√Hz1.1 %
Gain 225 kΩ20.34 nV/√Hz65.27 nV/√Hz5.2 %
Gain 2, 500 kΩ resistors250 kΩ64.3 nV/√Hz89.38 nV/√Hz44 %

Densities in V/√Hz. Noise powers add: 62.0² + 20.3² = 65.3².

The network alone gives √(4kT·RF ∥ RG). For 25 kΩ that is 20.3 nV/√Hz, and the lab reads the same from the two resistors.

Distortion Falls by 1 + T at the Harmonic

An amplifier that bends its output adds harmonics. HD2 is the second harmonic relative to the tone, in dBc, and HD3 is the third.

A harmonic is an error made inside the loop, after the gain. The loop senses it at the output and corrects it. It can correct by 1 + T, taken at the harmonic's own frequency.

Where Noise and Distortion Enter the LoopArrows show the signal path. Each error joins the path where it is made.
  • Source
  • I/O
  • Device
  • Data
Where noise and distortion enter the loopArrows show the signal path. Each error joins the path where it is made. source Input signal at the + input source Op-amp noise 62.0 nV/√Hz at 100kHz io Op-amp inputs signal minus returned source Network noise 20.3 nV/√Hz for 25kΩ device Gain A T = A/2 device Output stage bends: adds harmonics device RF and RG return half of theoutput signaladdsaddserroroutputreturned
  1. source Input signalat the + input
    • signal → Op-amp inputs
  2. source Op-amp noise62.0 nV/√Hz at 100 kHz
    • adds → Op-amp inputs
  3. source Network noise20.3 nV/√Hz for 25 kΩ
    • adds → Op-amp inputs
  4. io Op-amp inputssignal minus returned
    • error → Gain A
  5. device Gain AT = A/2
    • Output stage
  6. device Output stagebends: adds harmonics
    • output → RF and RG
  7. device RF and RGreturn half of the output
    • returned → Op-amp inputs
  1. Noise joins at the input

    Op-amp noise and network noise arrive where the signal arrives. The loop cannot tell them apart.

  2. So input noise is not divided

    The loop treats the noise as signal. The two noise powers add: 65.3 nV/√Hz at gain 2.

  3. Harmonics join after the gain

    The output stage makes the harmonic. The network returns it, and the loop divides it by 1 + T.

Read the diagram as text
  • Input signal: at the + input
  • Op-amp noise: 62.0 nV/√Hz at 100 kHz
  • Op-amp inputs: signal minus returned
  • Network noise: 20.3 nV/√Hz for 25 kΩ
  • Gain A: T = A/2
  • Output stage: bends: adds harmonics
  • RF and RG: return half of the output
  • Input signal → Op-amp inputs: signal
  • Op-amp noise → Op-amp inputs: adds
  • Network noise → Op-amp inputs: adds
  • Op-amp inputs → Gain A: error
  • Gain A → Output stage
  • Output stage → RF and RG: output
  • RF and RG → Op-amp inputs: returned

An error ahead of the gain passes as signal. An error after the gain is divided by 1 + T.

LoopHarmonic|1 + T| thereRuleRun
OpenHD2, 200 kHznonenone−59.06 dBc
Gain −1HD2, 200 kHz35.52 dB−94.58 dBc−94.13 dBc
Gain −9HD2, 200 kHz21.61 dB−80.66 dBc−80.23 dBc
OpenHD3, 300 kHznonenone−81.08 dBc
Gain −1HD3, 300 kHz32.03 dB−113.11 dBc−112.82 dBc
Gain −9HD3, 300 kHz18.14 dB−99.22 dBc−99.04 dBc

The rule is the open-loop level less |1 + T|. Every circuit has 0.2 V of output swing.

The rule and the run agree within 0.5 dB in all four cases. T is complex, so the lab adds 1 before it takes the magnitude.

The gain −9 loop has a fifth of the loop gain, and its harmonics are 14 dB higher.

The rule treats each harmonic alone. A strong HD2 can also mix with the tone inside the loop and add some HD3.

Compare at equal output swing. The output stage then works equally hard in every circuit, so it makes the same error.

Why Distortion Returns Near the Unity-Gain Frequency

DC sweepDistortion of the Gain −1 Loop Against the Tone FrequencyOutput swing 0.2 V at every point. The lower panel is the loop gain at the second harmonic.
  • HD2
  • HD3
  • T at twice the tone
-120 dB-100 dB-80 dB-60 dB-40 dB-20 dBHarmonic level110100T at the second harmonic100 kHz1 MHz10 MHzTone frequency2 MHz: HD2 = −58.2 dBc-120 dB-100 dB-80 dB-60 dB-40 dB-20 dBHarmonic level110100T at the second harmonic100 kHz1 MHz10 MHzTone frequency2 MHz: HD2 = −58.2 dBc
  1. Tone frequency 100 kHzHD2 = -94.13 dB · HD3 = -112.8 dB · T at twice the tone = 59.65

    At 100 kHz the second harmonic sees T = 59.7. HD2 is −94.1 dBc.

  2. Tone frequency 2 MHzHD2 = -58.16 dB · HD3 = -69.27 dB · T at twice the tone = 2.97

    At 2 MHz the second harmonic is at 4 MHz, where T is only 2.97. HD2 is −58.2 dBc.

Read the plot as a table
Tone frequencyHD2HD3T at twice the tone
100 kHz-94.13 dB-112.8 dB59.65
1 MHz-71.62 dB-89.9 dB5.968
2 MHz-58.16 dB-69.27 dB2.97

Six separate runs. The lab pins the 100 kHz and 2 MHz points.

T falls with frequency, and it reaches 1 near the unity-gain frequency fu. A harmonic above that frequency gets almost no correction.

At 2 MHz the lab prints hd2_g1_2meg = -5.816173e+01. That is about the open-loop level at 100 kHz, −59.1 dBc, with the loop closed.

A second effect adds to it. As T falls, the error voltage between the op-amp inputs grows, so the input pair starts to distort too.

Asked in interviews
  1. Does feedback improve the signal-to-noise ratio of an amplifier?

    No. Feedback divides the signal gain and the output noise by the same 1 + T, so the input-referred noise is unchanged. The feedback resistors then add their own thermal noise. Here 62.0 nV/√Hz became 65.3.

  2. How much noise does a feedback network add?

    The thermal noise of RF in parallel with RG, in series with the input: √(4kT·RF ∥ RG). It adds in power to the amplifier's own noise. For 25 kΩ it is 20.3 nV/√Hz.

  3. By how much does feedback reduce harmonic distortion?

    By about 1 + T, with T taken at the frequency of the harmonic, and compared at the same output swing. The lab's loop with T = 59.7 at 200 kHz lowers HD2 from −59.1 to −94.1 dBc.

  4. Why does a feedback amplifier distort more at high frequency?

    The loop gain falls with frequency, so harmonics near and above the unity-gain frequency are hardly corrected. The error voltage at the input also grows, and the input stage adds distortion of its own.

Try It

Part 1 reads the open-loop gain A. The loop gain is A/2 in loop A and A/10 in loop B.

drop is |1 + T| in dB. T stays complex until the magnitude is taken.

Part 2 runs noise four times. The last 1 on the second run also saves each device's share, which gives n_network.

Part 3 is one transient at 100 kHz. It skips 120 µs of start-up and keeps four periods. linearize puts them on a uniform grid.

The foreach loop multiplies the output by a cosine and a sine at each harmonic and integrates. That gives each harmonic's amplitude.

Part 4 moves the tone to 2 MHz with alter and repeats the measurement on loop A.

Predict before each change. Set RGB to 2.5k and VB to 10 mV: where do hd2_g9 and n_g10 move? Then remove the linearize line of part 3: which harmonic reading changes most?

SPICEngspice 42 · simulator service
Edit the netlist, then run it
Expected measurements: a_100k = 2.371481e+02 a_4meg = 5.941985e+00 drop2_g1 = 3.552342e+01 drop3_g1 = 3.202503e+01 drop2_g9 = 2.160703e+01 drop3_g9 = 1.814076e+01 n_open = 6.201608e-08 n_g2 = 6.527070e-08 n_g10 = 6.268064e-08 n_network = 2.034394e-08 n_g2_500k = 8.938033e-08 hd2_open = -5.905527e+01 hd3_open = -8.108169e+01 hd2_g1 = -9.412515e+01 hd3_g1 = -1.128244e+02 hd2_g9 = -8.023079e+01 hd3_g9 = -9.904270e+01 rule2_g1 = -9.457869e+01 rule3_g1 = -1.131067e+02 rule2_g9 = -8.066230e+01 rule3_g9 = -9.922245e+01 hd2_g1_2meg = -5.816173e+01 hd3_g1_2meg = -6.926799e+01

Check Yourself

Predict the outputThe noise figure's netlist prints net_only_100k = 2.035686e-08 for an ideal amplifier with RF = RG = 50 kΩ. Here both resistors are 200 kΩ. Type the line meas prints (format: n_in = 1.234567e-08).
* an ideal, noiseless amplifier with a gain of two: only its feedback resistors make noise
VP p 0 DC 0 AC 1
EA out 0 p f 1e9
RF out f 200k
RG f 0 200k
.control
noise v(out) VP dec 10 1k 100k
ac dec 10 1k 100k
let n_in=noise1.inoise_spectrum
meas ac n_in FIND n_in AT=10k
.endc
.end
ConceptRead the noise plot. At 1 kHz the open loop and the gain-2 loop both show 410 nV/√Hz. At 1 MHz they differ by 19 %. Why?
ConceptAn amplifier has −40 dBc of HD3 open loop at the swing you need. In the loop, T is 100 at the tone and 30 at the third harmonic. What HD3 do you expect?
ConceptA reviewer asks you to cut the noise of a gain-of-2 stage by raising the op-amp's open-loop gain 10 times. The input devices stay as they are. What happens to the input-referred noise?
ConceptRead the last plot. The gain −1 loop has −94.1 dBc of HD2 at 100 kHz and −58.2 dBc at 2 MHz, at the same swing. What is the main reason?

Common Mistakes

Wrong Close a loop, or raise its loop gain, to lower an amplifier's noise.

The loop divides signal and noise by the same factor, so the input-referred noise does not change.

Fix Lower noise where it is made: larger or better-biased input devices, and a smaller feedback network.

Wrong Choose large feedback resistors to save current, without a noise check.

RF ∥ RG sits in series with the input and adds √(4kT·R) of thermal noise.

Fix Compare the network's noise with the amplifier's own. In the lab a 500 kΩ pair raised the input noise by 44 %.

Wrong Predict a closed-loop harmonic with the loop gain at the tone.

The loop corrects the harmonic at the harmonic's frequency, where T is lower.

Fix Read T at 2f for HD2 and at 3f for HD3.

Wrong Read harmonics from a window that is not a whole number of periods.

The cut-off piece of the tone then leaks into every harmonic and can hide the real distortion.

Fix Save a whole number of periods and put them on a uniform grid before you correlate.

Before
tran 40n 160u 120u 40n
let d=v(oo)-mean(v(oo))
After
tran 40n 160u 120u 40n
linearize v(oo)
let d=v(oo)-mean(v(oo))

Remember

  • Feedback divides gain and output noise by the same 1 + T. Input-referred noise stays: 62.0 nV/√Hz open, never lower when closed.
  • The network adds √(4kT·RF ∥ RG) in series with the input. Powers add: 25 kΩ took 62.0 to 65.3 nV/√Hz.
  • A harmonic falls by about 1 + T at its own frequency, at equal output swing. The lab agrees within 0.5 dB.
  • T falls toward fu, so distortion returns: HD2 went from −94.1 dBc at 100 kHz to −58.2 dBc at 2 MHz.
  • Read harmonics over whole periods on a uniform grid, and measure the floor on a linear circuit.

Practice

Report a problem with this page