Return Ratio and Blackman's Formula

Measure the return ratio of one controlled source, then get the exact closed-loop gain and any port impedance from it.

You Will Be Able To

  • Measure the return ratio of a controlled source in a netlist.
  • Predict a closed-loop gain from the return ratio, the ideal gain and the direct feedthrough.
  • Find a port impedance from two return ratios with Blackman's formula.
  • Explain why a return ratio and a two-port loop gain can differ.
Lesson
E10.5
Time
35 min
Runs on
ngspice
Check
5 questions

An engineer put 1 kΩ in series with a follower's output to protect it. His note divided the total resistance by 1 + T and promised 1.44 kΩ, but the bench read 2.29 kΩ.

DC sweepOutput Resistance Against the Series ResistorThe follower of this lesson, as a linear model.
  • the run
  • Z0/(1 + T)
1.0 kΩ1.5 kΩ2.0 kΩ2.5 kΩ3.0 kΩ3.5 kΩOutput impedance0.5 kΩ1.0 kΩ1.5 kΩ2.0 kΩSeries resistor RISORISO = 1 kΩrun: 2.287 kΩrule: 1.441 kΩ1.0 kΩ1.5 kΩ2.0 kΩ2.5 kΩ3.0 kΩ3.5 kΩOutput impedance0.5 kΩ1.0 kΩ1.5 kΩ2.0 kΩSeries resistor RISORISO = 1 kΩrun: 2.287 kΩrule: 1.441 kΩ
  1. Series resistor RISO 20 Ωthe run = 1.307 kΩ · Z0/(1 + T) = 1.29 kΩ

    With almost no series resistor the two agree. The loop divides the follower's own resistance by 1 + T.

  2. Series resistor RISO 2 kΩthe run = 3.287 kΩ · Z0/(1 + T) = 1.594 kΩ

    At 2 kΩ the run reads 3.287 kΩ and the rule 1.594 kΩ. The loop does not shrink RISO.

Read the plot as a table
Series resistor RISOthe runZ0/(1 + T)
20 Ω1.307 kΩ1.29 kΩ
500 Ω1.787 kΩ1.364 kΩ
1 kΩ2.287 kΩ1.441 kΩ
1.5 kΩ2.787 kΩ1.517 kΩ
2 kΩ3.287 kΩ1.594 kΩ

The rule divides everything by one loop gain. The run does not.

One loop gain cannot describe every port, so this lesson measures two return ratios instead.

The Return Ratio of a Controlled Source

Measuring a Return Ratio on the Follower ModelG_M stands for the transistor. Node c is its control voltage.
Measuring a return ratio on the follower model++vin​gvt​cGM​g_m·v_cRs​8.381 kΩRISO​1 kΩouts
  1. v_in · voltage source+ → n1 · − → 0
  2. g · portterminal → n1
  3. v_t · voltage source+ → n2 · − → 0
  4. c · portterminal → n2
  5. G_M · current sourceg_m·v_c+ → 0 · − → s
  6. R_s · resistor8.381 kΩpin 1 → s · pin 2 → 0
  7. R_ISO · resistor1 kΩpin 1 → n3 · pin 2 → s
  8. out · portterminal → n3
  9. g1 · groundgnd → 0
  10. g2 · groundgnd → 0
  11. g3 · groundgnd → 0
  12. g4 · groundgnd → 0
  1. The closed loop

    G_M pushes gm·vc into node s. While the loop is closed, vc = vg − vs.

    gm·vc

  2. Zero the input

    Set vin to zero. The return ratio belongs to the loop alone.

  3. Break and drive

    Cut the control of G_M from the circuit. Drive node c with a test voltage vt.

  4. Read what returns

    The current gm·vt flows into Rs. The circuit returns vg − vs = −gm·Rs·vt.

    gm·vt

Read the circuit as text
  • v_in voltage source: + → n1, − → 0
  • g port: terminal → n1
  • v_t voltage source: + → n2, − → 0
  • c port: terminal → n2
  • G_M current source (g_m·v_c): + → 0, − → s
  • R_s resistor (8.381 kΩ): pin 1 → s, pin 2 → 0
  • R_ISO resistor (1 kΩ): pin 1 → n3, pin 2 → s
  • out port: terminal → n3

Rs = 1/(gmb + gds). Nothing loads the out pin here.

A controlled source sets its output from a voltage or current elsewhere. A transistor's gm is one.

The return ratio T of a controlled source is minus the returned signal divided by the test signal. Here T = gm·Rs.

The minus sign makes T positive for negative feedback. No feedback network was named: T belongs to the source and the whole circuit around it.

The lab copies gm and Rs from the SKY130 follower and prints t_open = 5.511562e+00.

Closed-Loop Gain from T and the Feedthrough

Two more runs give the exact gain. A∞ is the gain with a perfect controlled source. A0 is the gain with the source switched off, the direct feedthrough.

The follower has A∞ = 1 and A0 = 0. The formula gives g_formula = 8.464270e-01 and the transistor shows gain = 8.464269e-01.

The Feedback Pair of E10.2, Broken at M2A gate draws no current at 1 kHz, so this break is exact.
The feedback pair of E10.2, broken at M2++VDDVDDRD​60 kΩM1M2vt​d1RF​18 kΩR1​2 kΩvin​out
  1. VDD · supplyvdd → VDD
  2. VDD · supplyvdd → VDD
  3. R_D · resistor60 kΩpin 1 → VDD · pin 2 → n1
  4. M1 · NMOS transistorgate → n2 · drain → n1 · source → n3
  5. M2 · PMOS transistorgate → n4 · source → VDD · drain → n5
  6. v_t · voltage source+ → n4 · − → 0
  7. d1 · portterminal → n1
  8. R_F · resistor18 kΩpin 1 → n5 · pin 2 → n3
  9. R_1 · resistor2 kΩpin 1 → n3 · pin 2 → 0
  10. v_in · voltage source+ → n2 · − → 0
  11. g1 · groundgnd → 0
  12. g2 · groundgnd → 0
  13. g3 · groundgnd → 0
  14. out · portterminal → n5
  1. Return ratio

    Drive the gate of M2 with vt and read node d1. The lab prints t_rr = 9.300043e+00.

  2. A perfect M2

    Give M2 unlimited gm. The loop then forces the signal at d1 to zero: a_inf = 8.245674e+00.

  3. M2 switched off

    Hold the gate still. The input still reaches the output through M1 and RF: a_0 = 2.401716e-01.

    feedthrough

Read the circuit as text
  • R_D resistor (60 kΩ): pin 1 → VDD, pin 2 → n1
  • M1 NMOS transistor: gate → n2, drain → n1, source → n3
  • M2 PMOS transistor: gate → n4, source → VDD, drain → n5
  • v_t voltage source: + → n4, − → 0
  • d1 port: terminal → n1
  • R_F resistor (18 kΩ): pin 1 → n5, pin 2 → n3
  • R_1 resistor (2 kΩ): pin 1 → n3, pin 2 → 0
  • v_in voltage source: + → n2, − → 0
  • out port: terminal → n5

In the closed loop, the gate of M2 connects to d1.

QuantityLab line
A∞·T/(1 + T) + A0/(1 + T)7.468
Closed-loop gain in the run7.468

The formula is exact. The feedthrough term adds 0.023 to the gain.

Blackman's Formula for Any Port

A port is a pair of terminals where you measure an impedance. Blackman's formula needs three numbers at that port.

Three Measurements at One PortArrows show which measurement feeds the formula. The numbers are the follower model's.
  • I/O
  • Measure
  • Analysis
Three measurements at one portArrows show which measurement feeds the formula. The numbers are the follower model's. io The port out pin of thefollower model measure Source off Z_0 = 9.381 kΩ measure Port shorted T_short = 0.588 measure Port open T_open = 5.512 measure Blackman Z = 2.287 kΩ measure Direct run Z = 2.287 kΩ measure Zmeasure Tmeasure TZ_0times 1 + T shortover 1 + T openmatches
  1. io The portout pin of the follower model
    • measure Z → Source off
    • measure T → Port shorted
    • measure T → Port open
  2. measure Source offZ_0 = 9.381 kΩ
    • Z_0 → Blackman
  3. measure Port shortedT_short = 0.588
    • times 1 + T short → Blackman
  4. measure Port openT_open = 5.512
    • over 1 + T open → Blackman
  5. measure BlackmanZ = 2.287 kΩ
    • matches → Direct run
  6. measure Direct runZ = 2.287 kΩ
  1. The dead loop

    Switch the controlled source off and measure the port. That impedance is Z0.

  2. Two return ratios

    Measure T at the same controlled source twice: once with the port shorted, once with it open.

  3. Combine

    Multiply Z0 by 1 + Tshort and divide by 1 + Topen. The result matches the direct run.

Read the diagram as text
  • The port: out pin of the follower model
  • Source off: Z_0 = 9.381 kΩ
  • Port shorted: T_short = 0.588
  • Port open: T_open = 5.512
  • Blackman: Z = 2.287 kΩ
  • Direct run: Z = 2.287 kΩ
  • The port → Source off: measure Z
  • The port → Port shorted: measure T
  • The port → Port open: measure T
  • Source off → Blackman: Z_0
  • Port shorted → Blackman: times 1 + T short
  • Port open → Blackman: over 1 + T open
  • Blackman → Direct run: matches

The loop is never closed and probed at the port. Three simpler runs replace that.

PortZ0TshortTopenBlackmanDirect run
Follower model, out9.381 kΩ0.58755.5122.287 kΩ2.287 kΩ
Feedback pair, out16.87 kΩ09.3001.638 kΩ1.638 kΩ

Impedances in ohms. Both rows match the direct run to seven digits.

With the follower's out pin shorted, part of the test current flows through RISO. The loop still returns 0.588. That is why RISO is not divided by 1 + T.

Short the pair's output and M2's current goes to ground. Nothing returns, so Tshort = 0 and Z = Z0/(1 + T).

The rules of E10.1 are the two special cases. A shunt port has Tshort = 0 and divides. A series port has Topen = 0 and multiplies.

The transistor follower reads z_direct = 2.293491e+03, which is 0.28 % above the model. The model keeps only gm, gmb and gds.

When Return Ratio and Two-Port Loop Gain Differ

E10.2 analysed the same pair with the two-port method and found T = 9.48. The return ratio of M2 is 9.30.

MethodLoop gainPredicted gainPredicted Rout
Two-port (E10.2)9.487.5401.659 kΩ
Return ratio of M29.3007.4681.638 kΩ
The runnone7.4681.638 kΩ

The two-port row is 1.0 % high in gain and 1.3 % high in Rout.

The two-port method assumes signal flows forward only through the amplifier and back only through the network. Here M1 also drives the output through RF.

The return ratio makes no such assumption, so its predictions are exact. Its price is two extra runs for A∞ and A0.

Neither number is wrong. A loop gain is a property of a method, and each method must use its own companion terms.

Asked in interviews
  1. How do you find the return ratio of a transistor?

    Zero the independent sources. Cut the control of the gm source and drive it with a test signal. The return ratio is minus the signal that comes back, divided by the test signal.

  2. State Blackman's impedance formula.

    Z = Z0·(1 + Tshort)/(1 + Topen). Z0 is the port impedance with the controlled source off. The two return ratios are taken with the port shorted and with it open.

  3. Why does a resistor in series with a follower's output not shrink by 1 + T?

    The loop senses the voltage before the resistor. With the output pin shorted the loop still works, so Tshort is not zero. In the lab the result is 2.287 kΩ, where dividing by 1 + T gives 1.441 kΩ.

  4. A return ratio and a two-port loop gain disagree. Which is right?

    Both, within their own method. The return ratio with A∞ and A0 gives the exact gain. The two-port method ignores forward signal through the feedback network, so it is close but approximate.

Try It

Part 1 holds the SKY130 follower and its linear model. The alter lines copy gm and Rs from the operating point into GM and RS.

EC copies vg − vs onto node c while the loop is closed. Setting its gain to 0 cuts the control, and VT then drives it.

RP is the port switch. Runs 5 and 6 read the return ratio with the port open and shorted.

Part 2 is the pair of E10.2 and a copy. EK holds the copy's gate at the closed loop's DC level, so both sit at one operating point.

Predict before each change. Set RISO and RISOM to 100: how close do z_blackman and z_one_t come? Then set RF and RFB to 180k: does a_0 rise or fall?

SPICEngspice 42 · simulator service
Edit the netlist, then run it
Expected measurements: gm_mf = 6.576136e-04 rs_mf = 8.381147e+03 gain = 8.464269e-01 z_direct = 2.293491e+03 z_model = 2.287118e+03 z_0 = 9.381150e+03 t_open = 5.511562e+00 t_short = 5.875145e-01 z_blackman = 2.287118e+03 z_one_t = 1.440691e+03 g_formula = 8.464270e-01 g_closed = 7.468444e+00 rout_closed = 1.637840e+03 t_rr = 9.300043e+00 a_0 = 2.401716e-01 a_inf = 8.245674e+00 g_asym = 7.468444e+00 z0_pair = 1.686982e+04 z_pair = 1.637840e+03

Check Yourself

Predict the outputAn op-amp with a gain of 99 and 1 kΩ of output resistance is wired as a follower. A 100 Ω resistor sits between the loop and the out pin. Type the line meas prints for the output resistance (format: z_out = 1.234567e+02).
* an op-amp follower: gain 99, 1 k of output resistance, 100 ohm in series with the output
EA x 0 0 s 99
RO x s 1k
RISO s out 100
IT 0 out DC 0 AC 1
.control
ac dec 5 100 10k
meas ac z_out FIND vm(out) AT=1k
.endc
.end
ConceptRead the plot at the top of the lesson. RISO rises from 1 kΩ to 2 kΩ. By how much does the measured output resistance rise?
ConceptA port is made by cutting the one wire that carries a controlled source's output current. Which return ratio is zero, and what does Blackman's formula become?
ConceptThe bias of the feedback pair fails and the gm of M2 falls to almost zero. What does the gain from vin to out approach?
ConceptFor the same pair, the two-port method gives T = 9.48 and the return ratio of M2 is 9.30. What is the correct reading?

Common Mistakes

Wrong Divide every port impedance by 1 + T.

That holds only when shorting the port stops the loop, and a series port or a pin behind a resistor does not.

Fix Find Tshort and Topen for the port you care about, then apply Blackman's formula.

Wrong Leave the input source at AC 1 while you measure a return ratio.

The input's own signal then adds to the returned signal, so the ratio is no longer a property of the loop.

Fix Zero every independent source first. In the netlist, give each one AC 0.

Before
VINM g 0 DC 0 AC 1
alter EC gain=0
alter VT ac=1
After
VINM g 0 DC 0 AC 0
alter EC gain=0
alter VT ac=1

Wrong Cut the loop at a wire that carries current and call the result the return ratio.

Such a cut removes the loading that each side puts on the other, so the measured ratio belongs to a different circuit.

Fix Cut at the control of the controlled source. At low frequency a MOS gate is such a point.

Remember

  • To measure a return ratio: zero the inputs, cut the control of one controlled source, drive it, and read what returns.
  • The closed-loop gain is A∞·T/(1 + T) + A0/(1 + T). On the feedback pair it matches the run to seven digits.
  • Blackman: Z = Z0·(1 + Tshort)/(1 + Topen). A port that stops the loop when shorted gives Z0/(1 + T).
  • A resistor outside the sensing point is not reduced by the loop: 2.287 kΩ measured against 1.441 kΩ from the one-T rule.
  • Return ratio (9.30) and two-port loop gain (9.48) differ on the same circuit. Each belongs to its own formula.

Practice

Report a problem with this page